Best Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach

Top Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach

Plan your perfect getaway with our selection of vacation rentals in Mastic Beach. Each choice offers a blend of comfort and local charm, ideal for families and groups.

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball
House
164 Monroe Street, Mastic, NY, NY 11950, USA

Providing barbecue facilities, Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball offers accommodations in Mastic. This property offers access to a patio, mini-golf, free private parking, and free Wifi. The vacation home provides an outdoor swimming pool, hot tub, and a shared kitchen. The air-conditioned vacation home consists of 5 bedrooms, a living room, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and a coffee machine, and 3 bathrooms with a hot tub and bathrobes. Guests can take in the ambience of the surroundings from an outdoor dining area or keep warm by the fireplace on colder days. The vacation home offers bed linen, towels, and laundry service. Guests can also relax in the garden or on the sun terrace. Splish Splash is 16 miles from the vacation home, while Long Island Railroad is 22 miles away. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 14 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Laundry • Kitchen • Security/Safety • Ocean View • View • Guest Services • Balcony/Terrace • Hot Tub • Parking • Other • Air Conditioner • Sports/Activities

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Entire Waterfront Home with Panoramic Views of the Bay and Private Beach
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

Breath taking sunrises at this beachfront home enjoy your own private beach. Take in the sights on one of the Multiple decks to enjoy the amazing views of natural Long Island at its best! State of the art kitchen, water views from almost every room in the house spend your days lounging by the water fishing off the nearby dock steps away at Osprey Park. bring your jet skis and kyacks for hours of fun. multiple marinas nearby. Short drive to the Hamptons, and shopping

Guest Reviews:

- "Great" - "very helpful walkthrough of property upon arrival. house was beautiful clean with a lovely view, just 10-15 drive from gas and supermarket. very close to beaches and restaurants, 30-40min from vineyards, had a really good time" - "We had such an unbelievable time at Lana's beachfront home. This place is to die for - perfectly situated on the beach, with ample rooms and sleeping arrangements. The kitchen is spacious with lots of cabinet space. There is also a pretty ceremony space outdoors with an accompanying fire-pit, and lots of different seating spaces! Every room has a smart TV, and most have balconies and access to the outdoor views. A few of the rooms were missing curtains which made it a little tricky as the sun rose in the morning, but everything else was so ideal that we basically forgot about the small details! The host was harder to get ahold of at first, but was ultimately quite communicative, helpful, and sweet, and even brought over extra cleaning supplies when we ran out. The best part of this property was the bay at the bottom of the porch stairs, where we were greeted by beautiful swans and the most relaxing ocean air. Needless to say, we will be back! Thank you again Lana!"

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay
House
Mastic Beach, NY, USA

Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay offers accommodations in Mastic Beach, 24 miles from Long Island Railroad. Free Wifi is available throughout the property and Splish Splash is 20 miles away. Providing a patio and sea views, the spacious vacation home includes 3 bedrooms, a living room, cable flat-screen TV, an equipped kitchen, and 2 bathrooms with a bath and a shower. Towels and bed linen are provided in the vacation home. The property has an outdoor dining area. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 17 miles away.

Guest Reviews:

- "Our host was great to deal with, he met us at property and gave us a walk through the house."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
East End Retreat - Water Front - Available for the US Open Shinnecock Hills 2026
Cottage
Center Moriches, New York, USA

Welcome to East End Cottage, (25 minutes Shinnecock Hills 2026 US open) a beautifully renovated two-bedroom retreat with a loft, located right on Senix Creek Canal in Center Moriches, New York. This charming waterfront cottage is designed for relaxation, adventure, and family fun. Inside, guests will find a fully furnished space complete with modern comforts, an automated surround sound and TV system, plenty of board games, and even a wood-burning fireplace to cozy up by on cool evenings. Outside, the cottage opens to a large yard perfect for kids and pets, complete with a putting green, basketball court, fire pit, BBQ, and plenty of room to play.
The property sits directly on the water, with a private floating dock that offers docking for your own boat or jet ski, along with complimentary kayaks and paddle boards for exploring Senix Creek. Spend your mornings paddling along the bay, your afternoons enjoying nearby attractions like Splish Splash Water Park, Riverhead Aquarium, or the local petting zoo, and your evenings gathered around the fire pit under the stars.
East End Cottage is just minutes from the town of Center Moriches, about 15 minutes from the Hamptons, and nestled between two of Long Island’s most beautiful beaches, Smith Point Beach and Cupsogue Beach. Guests can enjoy wonderful nearby restaurants, a full list of local favorites provided upon arrival, or take a short ride to Tanger Outlets for a day of shopping in the sunshine. For wine lovers, the famous North Fork region is close by, where you can spend the day tasting at beautiful vineyards. And if you’re looking for a day trip, train and bus schedules are available to make exploring New York City easy and convenient.
With private parking, a pet-friendly policy, and sleeping space for extra guests in the loft, this waterfront cottage offers something for everyone. Whether you’re planning a family getaway, a romantic retreat, or simply a peaceful escape surrounded by natural beauty, East End Cottage is the perfect place to enjoy the best of Long Island year-round.

Guest Reviews:

- "Property was so beautiful, the house was very, very clean. Home was new and modern. Spacious bed rooms, and bathrooms. Very nice outside area. Prime location, short drive to ocean beaches. Cute town. Host was always quick to respond to any questions, and just so nice. I would love to come back and stay again! Thank you!" - "Lovely property, great communication with hosts. Very clean. Would definitely stay here again." - "Bright, airy, clean, and comfortable. A truly excellent home base for my family of five (incl. three kids 8-12) while we explored LI. Host was friendly, relaxed, and responsive. It’s a shared property with the host’s home, but still felt pretty private. Beach around the corner was quiet and beautiful, a huge bonus. Location is central on southern coast, residential in a town that is not touristy - exactly what we hoped for."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Cozy private rooms
House

Set in Mastic, within 26 km of Splish Splash and 34 km of Long Island Railroad, Cozy private rooms offers accommodation with a garden and free WiFi throughout the property as well as free private parking for guests who drive. The property is located 46 km from Agawam Park, 48 km from Bergen Point County Golf Course and 49 km from Neguntatogue Park. Guests can enjoy garden views. The units come with air conditioning, a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, a microwave, a kettle, a shower, a hairdryer and a desk. At the guest house all rooms are equipped with bed linen and towels. Cozy private rooms offers a continental or à la carte breakfast. Green Park is 49 km from the accommodation, while Firemens Memorial Park is 50 km away. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 24 km from Cozy private rooms.

Amenities:

Parking • Air Conditioner • Internet

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Waterfront Home with Dock! Amazing Views! Close To Beaches!
House
Shirley, New York, USA

A waterfront house overlooking the Great South Bay and Fire Island with 3 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms plus additional private outdoor shower, dock, kayaks, large wraparound decks with grill and outdoor dining table with umbrella, and open-concept living room/kitchen with wood-burning fireplace!
The house is located at the end of a cul-de-sac in a quiet neighborhood, directly overlooking the bay and wetlands. Great area for boating, kayaking, fishing, or simply relaxing. Walk to Smith Point Beach on Fire Island in 20 minutes! National wildlife refuge with hiking trails also nearby. Drive to Hamptons or North Fork in 25 to 30 minutes!
Appliances includes refrigerator, washer, dryer, dishwasher, microwave, 80-gallon hot water heater, and fully equipped kitchen. Internet and television provided. The private driveway accommodates up to 4 cars.
Note: for the safety of our guests and ourselves, there is a doorbell camera outside the front door.

Guest Reviews:

- "Great visit for our family. Great location and nice dock for my center console. Will be back some day we hope." - "We loved the views, the wildlife and the quiet neighborhood. Very pleased with the property. The owner was very friendly" - "The view of the sound from the deck, or from the kayaks, is incredibly relaxing. We really enjoyed our week with children and grandchildren." - "Love, love, love our stay at this home. Clean, quiet and scenic. I wish we could stay longer! Hope to see you next year! Thank you for sharing this wonderful here home with us."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less than 5 minutes to the beach!
House
90 Grandview Dr, Shirley, NY, NY 11967, USA

Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less than 5 minutes to the beach! offers accommodations in Shirley, 25 miles from Long Island Railroad. The air-conditioned accommodation is 19 miles from Splish Splash, and guests can benefit from on-site private parking and complimentary Wifi. Featuring a patio and sea views, the spacious vacation home includes 3 bedrooms, a living room, flat-screen TV, an equipped kitchen, and 1 bathroom with a bidet and a shower. Towels and bed linen are available in the vacation home. The property has an outdoor dining area. Guests can relax in the garden at the property. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 17 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Security/Safety • Internet • Other • Parking • View • Air Conditioner • Guest Services • Child Friendly • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Smith Point Ocean Breeze, Cape charm with Modern Twist in bayside community
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

Our home is located 3 blocks from marina and the Bay, short drive to Fire Island National Seashore and Smith Point Ocean Beach. It is newly renovated, with central air, 3 Bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, open concept kitchen and dining room, living room, Netflix, WiFi, fenced backyard, patio with outdoor furniture, BBQ and outdoor ping-pong table. It provides great space for family and friends, (pets are considered) to hang out, and relax; it is good starting point for exploring many local attractions:
- 3 blocks to marina on the bay
- about 5 min. by bike or car to William Floyd Estate.
- about 15 min by car to Wertheim National Wildlife Refuge
-about 10 min by car to Smith Point Ocean Beaches where you can enjoy swimming, paddle-boarding, surfing, fishing
- about 25 min by car to Westhampton Beach
-about 30 min to Riverhead: Splish-Splash Water Park, and Aquarium
-about 1 hour and 30 min to Manhattan by car or train

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a fantastic stay here! The place was immaculately clean, beautifully furnished, and located close to the beach. The host was incredibly accommodating and ensured we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. We enjoyed every moment and can't wait to return. Highly recommended!" - "The home was clean. Well stocked with all the amenities from dishes to linens. great location to the beach and stores." - "The property was wonderful. The house had so many amenities including items for the beach. The backyard totally enclosed made for a very comfortable stay."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Architectural Bayview House
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

Our house does not have AC but has standing fans and generally has a good bay breeze as its quiet near the water.

Spacious house with large wrap around deck, stainless steel appliances, 3 bedrooms (one master bedrooms with a queen bed, two bedrooms with two queen beds and one extra queen bed mattress), 2 full baths and large living room. Wi-Fi internet and BBQ. House is at the edge of a small wetlands reserve and is near the bay overlooking fire island. Fire Island's Smith Point Beach is a 4 mile drive with a pristine sandy beach.

We have a small outdoor propane firepit seen in the photos and inside a wood burning stove.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a great time in Mastic Beach! The views of the bay - practically a bird sanctuarty - enhanced the experience. Large open plan home with room for everything & everyone. Prompt attention from host. Short drive to Fire Island beach. Would stay again!" - "Native long islanders we've outgrown the ability to "stay" with family and rented this house to visit family and soak in the beauty of the east end beaches. We hosted a lovely cookout on the porch which has the most serene views and enjoyed short drives to the ocean beaches where we head to daily. House has a lot of space - only downside was no AC but even in the heat of summer we only missed in a couple of nights."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Peaceful Family Escape Near the Hamptons – 40 Foot Pool, 90 Minutes from NYC
House
Center Moriches, New York, USA

Trade city stress for sunshine and space at this family-friendly retreat just steps from Moriches Bay. Set on a quiet ¾-acre property, this house blends cozy comfort with playful, vintage-inspired interiors—think curated decor, warm touches, and spaces that feel like home. It is the ideal spot for families to unwind, explore, and reconnect—all without the Hamptons traffic.

Spend sunny days in the large 40x20-foot pool, or relaxing on the large deck with ample seating. There's plenty of room to run and play in the open yard, enjoy a quiet morning coffee, or use the custom copper outdoor shower perfect for rinsing off after beach adventures. A local sandy beach is just five minutes away, and a front porch to unwind from the day or enjoy sunset snacks.

You’ll be perfectly positioned to explore both the Hamptons and the North Fork, or just relax and enjoy the slower pace. Ask us for our favorite restaurants, nearby farm stands, and hidden gems—we’re happy to share!

Please note the pool is only open to renters between Memorial Day and Labor Day.

Guest Reviews:

- "This is the second year in a row that I have stayed here and I have every intention of returning again next year. Everything is well maintained. It is fully equipped, beautifully decorated and the pool is wonderful. Mary is easy to communicate with and very responsive which us key when renting properties." - "My family and I had an incredibly positive experience at Mary's home in Moriches. The pool was definitely the highlight. We used it every day. It was clean and the perfect size and depth for our needs. The home itself was also beautiful and clean. The beds, especially the pillows, were extremely comfortable. The kitchen had all the utensils and items needed and the layout was perfect for cooking and hanging out. Mary was responsive and helpful. We look forward to returning in the future!"

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Hottub, ⛳️, htd pool, Sauna, Basketball nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn
House
Mastic, New York, USA

Welcome to Paradise Citadel
A4-person luxury Sauna is ready to use.

We're excited to host you in our property Feature, hottub, pool, putting green, Basketball court, firepits, volleyball net, pickball net. My wife and I can't wait for guests to explore this home and make memorable moments with their loved ones

Hottub is year round
Pool table
Basketball court
Firepit, propane tank provided.
Golf putting green, putters and golf balls provided.
soccer ball
Kid swig set, age 8 to 10 years old

Upper Floor; 4 bedrooms 1 bath
Ground Floor; 1 bedroom 1 bath
Basement 1 bedroom 1 bath
2 sofa beds
1 toddler bed
2 air mattresses
The kitchen has everything a family will need to host a family gathering.
Driveway can accommodate up to 7 cars.

Guest Reviews:

- "Awesome house, bedrooms were beautiful. The highlight of this property is definitely the backyard. There are so many things to do out there and it was loads of fun!" - "All of us enjoyed our stay. The house is spacious and well kept. Jacuzzi was awesome. The property was well maintain. Fire Island was 7 minutes away. If we go to Long Island next year we would love to stay here." - "From end to end, it was a great experience! Clean, comfortable, and easy to locate! Just about everything you could need is already on premise. Great communication with host who was very responsive and attentive. Tons of activities for a variety of ages and interests. Closely located to shopping and highway. Highly recommend."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
“The Cool House” Waterfront Oasis, 3 Bedrm 2 bath
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

Discover the “Cool House” This is the coolest waterfront getaway on the south shore of Long Island! Waking up to beautiful sunrises, dinners with a sunset every night & dancing under the stars is a lifestyle your family & friends will cherish forever.

The perfect escape from NYC, minutes from the Atlantic Ocean & just a short drive to the Hamptons! This meticulously renovated oasis is the perfect living & entertaining space, a trendy retro beach vibe designed for fun or relaxation.

Nicknamed by our 3 year old son, "The Cool House" has an open concept design, vaulted ceilings with large windows that create amazing natural light. Multiple sliding glass doors lead to an oversized raised deck with modern stainless steel cable railings, overlooking stunning views of the Moriches Bay. Fully renovated with luxurious finishes, newly furnished, awesome art and new memory foam mattresses throughout! Cuddle up & enjoy the warmth from the stacked stone gas fireplace, enjoy complementary WiFi, Netflix and YouTube TV or enjoy your favorite sports game on the 55” flat screen. Take a picture in the surfboard chair, You can even Ask Alexa to play your favorite soundtrack!

Some more on the space:

Bedroom 1: Master bedroom-
Queen bed, 2 Separate closest & connecting full bathroom. (Located on 1st floor)

Bedroom 2: Guest Bedroom-
Queen bed, large closet, vaulted ceilings. (Located on 1st floor)

Bedroom 3: Open Loft-
Awesome spiral staircase leads to 2 Full size trundle beds, with 2 pull out twin beds, oversized closet with desk, vaulted ceilings & access to a private outdoor balcony with a cute little table and chairs where you can enjoy the morning sunrise. (Located on 2nd floor)

Bathroom 1: Large master bathroom on suite with tub/shower combo. (Located on 1st floor)

Bathroom 2: Shared bathroom
In hallway, including stand up shower. (Located on 1st floor)

Lower level: Cant forget the Game Room/lounge!
The sweet spiral staircase continues to the lower level which Includes pool table, air hockey, foosball, ping pong, card games, comfy outdoor style sofa/chairs & more!

Outdoor Space: Oversized deck with outdoor sofa & chairs, cushions galore, gas fireplace, outdoor table with seating for 8, multiple umbrellas, lighting, stainless steel propane BBQ, private outdoor shower area, 4 swings for the kids, 3 kayaks, woods burning fire pit, outdoor yard games available in shed, fully fenced in grass yard, with enough space and safety for the kids to run around!

Guest Reviews:

- "This was a wonderful place for my family of 6 children, 2 adults to stay. Even though it rained most of the time there was still plenty to do with all the fun games downstairs. We loved everything about the house and would definitely stay again. Thank you for making our visit so comfortable and relaxing." - "This place was tucked away in a great location. Right on the bay and kayaks allow you to explore anywhere in the area. I was able to communicate with Daniel the entire time with any questions and the neighbor we met was awesome! Perfect spot to relax or take a trip to the Hamptons, Montauk, or even the mainland."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Beautiful home in Center Moriches- 10 miles from Westhampton Beach.
House
Center Moriches, New York, USA

Beautiful private house and grounds, perfect for fun and relaxation! This 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home is fully equipped inside and out! Outdoor features a heated pool, outdoor wood burning fire place and two level deck with a BBQ and plenty of sitting and lounging space. Indoor features a living room with a bar area, family room with a wood burning fire place, work station and dining room. The whole first floor has an open layout. Game room in the basement includes two separate tables of pool and ping pong. Front yard has a lovely deck with rocking chairs. You may not want to leave!
Salt water POOL IS OPEN UNTIL MID OCT (Weather permitting)

**Please note that there are 3 exterior surveillance cameras on the property for security purposes. One facing the driveway/front yard area, one facing the front entrance/front yard area and one covering the back yard including decks and pool**

Location/Area:

-1.5 hrs drive from NYC
-Train from NYC to Speonk train station which is 6 miles from the house (12 min UBER ride)
-5 min from a beautiful and calm bay beach (Webby Beach) which has a big playground.
-Lots of restaurants and ice cream shops
-Big public library with a children’s room
-7 min from a highly rated golf course (Pine Hills Golf & Country Club)
-8 min from Animal Farm Petting Zoo
-10 min to a Terrell River county park which has hiking trails that lead to the beach
-17 min to Riverhead for outlet shopping and wineries
-20 min to West Hampton Beach
-30 min to Mattituck for Fall farm experience with the kids

Guest Reviews:

- "The house has everything for a great stay. Very well appointed, comfortable and modern. Everyone in our family had a great time and voted to come back next year." - "Had a wonderful stay. The house was perfect for the 8 of us. Loved everything! There were plenty of clean towels for both pool and showers, all easy to find. The pool was great and very relaxing. They even had pool floats which we enjoyed using. Was a wonderful location. Easy to find off main road and near Hamptons coffee and a great Mexican restaurant with outdoor seating. Would definitely go back."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Mastic Beach Surf House
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

The cure for anything is salt water: sweat, tears or the sea-Isak Dinesen. Escape to this tranquil and sunny waterfront oasis only 70 miles from NYC in Mastic Beach! Come by yourself or bring the family and/or close friends to this recently renovated home step to a bay beach and Marina.
The home sleeps 6 comfortably: the primary bedroom and a second bedroom both come with queen-size beds and the third bedroom has two single beds. The open and expansive living, dining and kitchen area is great for spending time together enjoying cooking, entertaining and the never-ending water views. The home is truly the epitome of waterfront living. Open all the windows and you get an ocean cross-breeze second to none. We have all the necessities one may need to spend a relaxing and enjoyable time. Walk across to a small bay beach or Kayak to the isolated part of Fire Island and swim its pristine water. Pick up fresh oysters from our neighbor that owns Violet Cove Oysters. Bring your bicycles and enjoy riding by the waterfront and Marina area.

There are endless trails for hiking and bird watching in the nearby 600 acre William Floyd estate. There are fishing options all around the house and Smith Point is perfect for surf casting. Mastic Beach is a diverse working-class small town with a great old school Italian restaurant, an amazing butcher and two great bait and tackle shops. A short drive to Mastic Seafood will get you the highest quality and largest selection of seafood around. If you are planning a more upscale dinner, restaurants in Bellport, Patchogue, or East Moriches are great options.

The house is available year round and makes a great fall retreat or winter getaway.

Steps away from Narrow Bay.
8 minute drive to Smith Point Park and Fire Island National Seashore.
11 miles to the Village of Bellport
12 miles to Westhampton Beach

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a wonderful stay and Frank is a gracious and very responsive host! The house was immaculately clean and had everything we needed. We especially loved using the fire pit. Highly recommend!" - "My stay at Frank's was wonderful! My dog and I loved walking the beach across the way every morning. Frank is really communicative and gives great recommendations. The place was cozy and lovely - I will be back and I recommend to others :)"

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Waterfront home with amazing views
House
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

The sea is a balm for the soul, where we can leave the information age and reconnect with nature. Escape to this tranquil waterfront oasis only 70 miles from NYC in Mastic Beach! Come by yourself or bring the family and/or close friends to this just renovated home on stilts with 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths. The home sleeps 7 comfortably: the master bedroom and a second bedroom both come with queen-size beds and the third bedroom has a bunk bed with a trundle option that can sleep three. There is a separate den with a queen size pull out couch for last minute guests. The open and expansive living, dining and kitchen area is great for spending time together enjoying cooking, entertaining and the never-ending water views. Kayak to the isolated part of Fire Island and swim its pristine water. Get fresh oysters delivered from our neighbor that owns Violet Cove Oysters.

There are endless trails for hiking and bird watching in the nearby 600 acre William Floyd estate. There are fishing options all around the house and Smith Point is perfect for surf casting. Mastic Beach is a small town with a great old school Italian restaurant, an amazing butcher and two great bait and tackle shops. A short drive to Mastic Seafood will get you the highest quality and largest selection of seafood around. If you are planning a more upscale dinner, restaurants in Bellport, Patchogue, or East Moriches are great options.

The house is available year round and makes a great fall retreat or winter getaway.

Steps away from Narrow Bay.
5 minute drive to Smith Point Park and Fire Island National Seashore.
11 miles to the Village of Bellport
12 miles to Westhampton Beach.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a wonderful stay at this well-appointed vacation rental. The views are incredible and we enjoyed the quiet neighborhood with short drives to restaurants and the beach. The home is also very close to the Hamptons and we enjoyed driving all the way to the Montauk lighthouse. The beds were super comfortable and the house very clean. It’s an older home but everything was well-maintained. There were plenty of towels and dishes. We were lucky to have great weather and enjoyed bonfires (with deer visiting!) and walks. Frank was very responsive and helpful. We also tried out a couple of the recommended restaurants (Painter’s and Onofrio’s), which were very good! Thank you for taking the time to make this house so welcoming. We had a wonderful time."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Private Cottage
Apartment
Mastic Beach, New York, USA

Small unit suitable for single traveler.
Complete with twin size captain bed, full kitchen and bath. Dish tv and WiFi. Very quiet place, high ceilings, wood flooring, large windows gives it an airy feel. Close to the beach and local eateries.

Guest Reviews:

- "Before I begin, I want to mention that it is a single bed. The place is only good for one person. The bottom line is that the place is clean, has a very comfortable bed, a full kitchen, I think adequate air conditioning (it never got into the 90's, so I am not sure), and fast internet (over 100 mbs) for a VERY low price relative to LI. The trade-off is that the place is older, but the price more than makes up for that. If I ever visit central LI again, I will look this place up."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Tranquil Stay
House
Shirley, New York, USA

Welcome to our beautiful 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom single-family home that has everything you need for a comfortable and enjoyable stay. Our home is perfect for families or groups of friends looking for a relaxing retreat with all the amenities.
As you walk in, you'll immediately notice the spacious living room with comfortable seating and a large flat-screen TV, perfect for relaxing after a long day of exploring the area. The living room flows into the fully equipped kitchen, complete with stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and all the cooking essentials you need to prepare your favorite meals.
The dining room adjacent to the kitchen has a large table that can seat up to six guests, perfect for enjoying meals together. From the dining room, step outside onto the patio, where you can enjoy the outdoors and soak up the sun. The patio has a grill and outdoor seating, making it the perfect spot for a BBQ or to relax with a cup of coffee.
The home has three bedrooms, each with comfortable beds and plenty of closet space. The master bedroom has a king-size bed and an en-suite bathroom with a double vanity, shower and soaking tub, perfect for relaxing after a long day. The two additional bedrooms each have a queen-size bed and share a full bathroom with a shower/tub combination.
Our home is equipped with all the amenities you need for a comfortable and enjoyable stay, including high-speed Wi-Fi, air conditioning, heating, and a washer and dryer. We also provide fresh linens, towels, and basic toiletries for your convenience.
We are located in a quiet and peaceful neighborhood, perfect for relaxing and unwinding. Our home is just a short drive away from all the attractions the area has to offer, including beautiful beaches, golf courses, and restaurants.
We look forward to welcoming you to our beautiful home and providing you with a comfortable and memorable stay!

Guest Reviews:

- "The property was just as described and looked like the pictures posted. The home was clean and well stocked. Perfect location - not far from the highways. Great communication with the owner. Will stay there again when visiting Long Island. My family enjoyed their stay. Thank you for hosting us!" - "Great stay with family to see a couple of our son's shows at the Gateway Theatre. Thank you Andre for be a great host...!!!" - "10/10 highly recommended "

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Beachfront Sunrise to Sunset Water Views - Dreamy Getaway
House
Center Moriches, New York, USA

Breathe in the sea air. Relax on the front deck. Wake up and step onto the sand for some beach yoga. Gaze at stars all night long. Don’t forget to enjoy miles of hiking trails at the end of our road, and always a quick ride to great surfing beaches. Save some time for the hammock that’ll make you feel like you’re a boat on the water and enjoy the outdoor bbq and fire pit for s’mores. Fishing and relaxing and boogie boarding and biking are also lots of fun. Maximum rentals are 24 nights. If you'd like to stay longer separate inquiries and bookings are needed, we will do our best to work it out.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had the most wonderful stay at this pristine waterfront home. My husband and two children woke up to rosy sunrises and watched egrets and gulls catch their breakfast from the kitchen table. The kids built sandcastles, hunted for shells and played with friends in the shallow bay mere steps from the backyard. The house is located just a few minutes from a café, ice cream shop, delicious bakery and a seafood restaurant, not to mention several other local attractions and activities on and off the water. The second floor was equipped with beautiful water views and comfortable beds and bean bags that my kids loved lounging in. They are already asking when we can back. It was a joy to be on the water and air with a book and a cup of coffee or a glass of wine. We made s’mores around the fire pit and watched a family of swans swim by every evening. Tami is an excellent communicator and added special touches like a welcome treat from a famous local cookie shop. The house had everything we could need - from linens to kid’s cups. Thank you for sharing such a special place with our family! We can’t wait to come back next summer."

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
"The Blue Door" House Waterfront
House
Center Moriches, New York, USA

About this space
Forget your worries in this spacious and serene place. Newly constructed and furnished, the house is located in a quiet peaceful neighborhood, yet a short walking distance to Main street with a variety of great shops and restaurants. Private access to Creek that leads out to Moriches Bay. You can go kayaking or simply enjoy waterview and nature by the fire pit.
Close to the Hamptons, amazing beaches, North Fork vineyards and a train ride away from Manhattan.

Guest Reviews:

- "we decided to stay here to start off our spring break and we were so happy we came here and not anywhere else. the house was so lovely we just hung out there the whole night and had a great time. the house is extremely spacious and modern and the property as a whole is huge and leads down to the water where there is a nice hangout area. we definitely will be coming back here as not only the house was amazing but the host as well. plus i also think the price is amazing considering all things offered. 10/10 reccomend. "

Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach
Waterside Pine Haven- Close to the Hamptons
House
Center Moriches, New York, USA

Welcome to Your Cozy Fall Retreat in Center Moriches!

Escape to the serene beauty of Center Moriches this fall and experience the perfect blend of comfort and nature. Our tranquil oasis is a place where nature and architecture harmonize, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for a relaxing getaway.

Enjoy breathtaking views of vibrant fall colors right from your window. Snuggle up by the fireplace with a good book or a cup of hot cocoa. Gather around the fire pit in the evening for marshmallow roasting and stargazing. Savor fresh produce from nearby farmers' markets, and enjoy apple picking and pumpkin patches. Located just minutes from the beach, wineries, and charming local shops, our property offers the best of both relaxation and adventure.

Designed with Frank Lloyd Wright’s principles in mind, our home seamlessly blends into its natural surroundings with a knotty pine interior, concrete walls, skylights, and large windows. Our spacious home accommodates large groups, making it perfect for family gatherings or retreats. Enjoy our large yard with a private waterfront, and watch for deer, rabbits, and many birds as you relax in nature. Surrounded by tall trees, there is a sense of privacy and tranquility. We’re a short drive from Manhattan and the Hamptons, offering easy access to both city and coastal attractions.

Our amenities include a spacious living area with comfortable seating, a fully equipped kitchen for all your culinary needs, cozy bedrooms with plush bedding, high-speed Wi-Fi and smart TV, an outdoor seating area with BBQ grill, and private parking.

Book your stay today and create unforgettable fall memories in Center Moriches. We look forward to hosting you!

Exterior cameras on the property

Close to many towns & attractions:
The Hamptons- 15 min away
Northfork
Montauk

Ocean Beaches:
Cupsogue Beach County Park, Westhampton
Ponquogue Beach, Hampton Bays
Shinnecock East County Park, Southampton
Coopers Beach, Southampton
Main Beach, E. Hampton Village
Kirk Park Beach, Montauk
Smith Point Beach

Bay Beaches:
Meschutt Beach County Park, Hampton Bays
Foster Memorial Beach, Sag Harbor
New Suffolk Beach, New Suffolk
Orient Beach State Park, Orient
Crescent Beach, Shelter Island

Sound Beaches:
Iron Pier Beach, Jamesport
Breakwater Beach, Mattituck
Town Beach, Southold
67 Steps Beach, Greenport
Wading River Beach, Wading River

Water Parks & Adventure Parks:
Splish Splash Water Park
Scotte’s Pointe Adventure Park

Shopping: Riverhead Tanger Outlets

Skydiving: Long Island Skydiving Center- Shirley

Kayaking & Canoeing:
Carman's River Canoe & Kayak - Brookhaven
Get Salty Adventures- East Moriches
Adventure Paddleboards- Hampton Bays
Paumanok Tours- Setauket
Peconic Paddler- Riverhead

Wineries & Breweries:
Greenport Harbor Brewing Company
Southampton Publick House
Blue Point Brewing Company
Shinn Estate Vineyards- Mattituck
Roanoke Vineyards- Riverhead
Palmer Vineyards- Riverhead
North Fork Wine Guide- Greenport

Museums & Historic Sites:
Horton Point Lighthouse, Southold
The Old House, Cutchogue
Hallock Ville Museum Farm, Riverhead
Oyster Ponds Historical Society, Orient
Railroad Museum of Long Island, Riverhead, Greenport
Village Blacksmith, Greenport
East End Seaport Museum, Greenport
Suffolk County Historical Society, Riverhead
Oyster Ponds Historical Society, Orient
Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum, Montauk
Parrish Art Museum, Southampton
South Fork Natural History Museum, Bridgehampton
The Sag Harbor Whaling & Historical Museum, Sag Harbor
Pollock-Krasner House and Study Center, Springs
Rogers Mansion, Southampton
Guild Hall, East Hampton

Guest Reviews:

- "Great property great hosts" - "The home was comfortable and spacious! Check in was simple and everything went smoothly. " - "Rented this charming home for a family reunion weekend. Host was readily available for questions but otherwise not intrusive. Host was kind to leave bottled water, condiments, ample paper products, etc. Beds were comfortable with soft linens. Waterfront property was large, lush & private. We were fortunate to see wild deer visiting the yard during our stay. Lovely and safe neighborhood. Fast food options within minutes & Moriches Brewery within stumbling distance home. Located 15 minutes from Islip McArthur airport. Highly recommend and will be our first choice when visiting family on Long Island."

Mastic Beach Family Friendly Vacation rentals

Mastic Beach Vacation rentals with Parking

Mastic Beach Pet Friendly Vacation rentals

Mastic Beach Vacation rentals with Entertainment

Mastic Beach Vacation rentals with Private Pool

Mastic Beach Vacation rentals with Spa

Mastic Beach Vacation-Rentals on the Map

Compare the Best Vacation-Rentals in Mastic Beach – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Property Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball 164 Monroe Street, Mastic, NY, NY 11950, USA 350 4.0 10.0 1 Click here
Entire Waterfront Home with Panoramic Views of the Bay and Private Beach Mastic Beach, New York, USA 705 2.0 9.8 14 Click here
Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay Mastic Beach, NY, USA 236 3.0 9.0 3 Click here
East End Retreat - Water Front - Available for the US Open Shinnecock Hills 2026 Center Moriches, New York, USA 783 10.0 105 Click here
Waterfront Home with Dock! Amazing Views! Close To Beaches! Shirley, New York, USA 342 10.0 91 Click here
Waterfront Designer Retreat! Stunning Sunsets! Less than 5 minutes to the beach! 90 Grandview Dr, Shirley, NY, NY 11967, USA 388 1 Click here
Smith Point Ocean Breeze, Cape charm with Modern Twist in bayside community Mastic Beach, New York, USA 256 9.8 77 Click here
Architectural Bayview House Mastic Beach, New York, USA 474 9.0 53 Click here
Peaceful Family Escape Near the Hamptons – 40 Foot Pool, 90 Minutes from NYC Center Moriches, New York, USA 578 10.0 28 Click here
Hottub, ⛳️, htd pool, Sauna, Basketball nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn Mastic, New York, USA 1161 10.0 27 Click here
“The Cool House” Waterfront Oasis, 3 Bedrm 2 bath Mastic Beach, New York, USA 387 10.0 23 Click here
Beautiful home in Center Moriches- 10 miles from Westhampton Beach. Center Moriches, New York, USA 257 10.0 18 Click here
Mastic Beach Surf House Mastic Beach, New York, USA 307 10.0 15 Click here
Waterfront home with amazing views Mastic Beach, New York, USA 434 10.0 14 Click here
Private Cottage Mastic Beach, New York, USA 111 8.6 9 Click here
Tranquil Stay Shirley, New York, USA 439 8.4 9 Click here
Beachfront Sunrise to Sunset Water Views - Dreamy Getaway Center Moriches, New York, USA 796 10.0 8 Click here
"The Blue Door" House Waterfront Center Moriches, New York, USA 428 10.0 6 Click here
Waterside Pine Haven- Close to the Hamptons Center Moriches, New York, USA 599 10.0 4 Click here

Note: The prices for each Vacation-Rentals in Mastic Beach do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Vacation rentals in Mastic Beach that include a pool include:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Peaceful Family Escape Near the Hamptons – 40 Foot Pool, 90 Minutes from NYC.- Review Count: 28, Rating: 10.0
  • Hottub, ⛳️, htd pool, Sauna, Basketball nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn.- Review Count: 27, Rating: 10.0

These vacation rentals in Mastic Beach provide spa or wellness access:

  • Cozy and Stylish 1 Bedroom Guest Suite .- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0

Family-friendly vacation rentals in Mastic Beach include:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Entire Waterfront Home with Panoramic Views of the Bay and Private Beach.- Review Count: 14, Rating: 9.8
  • Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay.- Review Count: 3, Rating: 9.0

Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Mastic Beach include:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • East End Retreat - Water Front - Available for the US Open Shinnecock Hills 2026.- Review Count: 105, Rating: 10.0
  • Smith Point Ocean Breeze, Cape charm with Modern Twist in bayside community.- Review Count: 77, Rating: 9.8

Vacation rentals in Mastic Beach that include breakfast options include:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • “The Cool House” Waterfront Oasis, 3 Bedrm 2 bath.- Review Count: 23, Rating: 10.0

Vacation rentals in Mastic Beach with private or on-site parking include:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay.- Review Count: 3, Rating: 9.0
  • East End Retreat - Water Front - Available for the US Open Shinnecock Hills 2026.- Review Count: 105, Rating: 10.0

Some of the best Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach are:

  • Paradise Citadel, Htd pool hottub Golf Basketball.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Waterfront Home with Large Deck and Dock on Narrow Bay.- Review Count: 3, Rating: 9.0
  • Entire Waterfront Home with Panoramic Views of the Bay and Private Beach.- Review Count: 14, Rating: 9.8

Some of the popular Vacation Rentals in Mastic Beach are:

  • East End Retreat - Water Front - Available for the US Open Shinnecock Hills 2026.- Review Count: 105, Rating: 10.0
  • Waterfront Home with Dock! Amazing Views! Close To Beaches!.- Review Count: 91, Rating: 10.0
  • Smith Point Ocean Breeze, Cape charm with Modern Twist in bayside community.- Review Count: 77, Rating: 9.8