Best Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Top Vacation Rentals in Fire Island

Plan your perfect getaway with our selection of vacation rentals in Fire Island. Each choice offers a blend of comfort and local charm, ideal for families and groups.

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Huron Hideaway
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Huron Hideaway offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a few steps from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. The vacation home also offers facilities for disabled guests. The air-conditioned vacation home also features a TV, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, a seating area, washing machine, and 2 bathrooms with a walk-in shower. The property has an outdoor dining area. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from the vacation home, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles from the property.

Guest Reviews:

- "Amazing location and the house is super well equipped with everything you need to feel at home. The surroundings are bea" - "Absolutely super experience all round. A fabulous visit"

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Grove Hotel
Hotel
1 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, Sayville, NY, 11782, USA

Boardwalk/promenade hotel with a nightclub and a seasonal outdoor pool
A restaurant, a nightclub, and a bar/lounge are available at this hotel. WiFi in public areas is free. Other amenities include a poolside bar, a coffee shop/cafe, and a microwave in a common area.
Housekeeping is available on request.
Grove Hotel offers 63 air-conditioned accommodations with hair dryers and complimentary toiletries. 42-inch Smart televisions come with digital channels.

Bathrooms include showers. This Sayville hotel provides complimentary wireless Internet access, with a speed of 50+ Mbps. Irons/ironing boards, change of towels, and change of bedsheets can be requested. Housekeeping is provided on request. Renovation of all guestrooms was completed in May 2023.


Recreational amenities at the hotel include a seasonal outdoor pool.

The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.

Guest Reviews:

- "Great renovation " - "Nice, convenient, value. " - "Very accommodating and on point, can’t wait to come back " - "Everything was great. Thank you as always." - "All redone nice and clean and nice people" - "First time staying in Cherry Grove after years in the Pines. Was excited to have a different scene. Hotel was ok, you can tell it had been updated recently. Hotel is connected to the Ice Palace, so at night you could hear and feel the music, they do supply earplugs which helped a lot since I get up early. The walls are very thin so you can hear everything around you, it felt like a dorm, people having a great time and screaming in the hallway at all hours. Ended up leaving a day early, it was stormy so no beach & wifi/ chrome cast to tv was not working. "

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Fire Island Gem
Apartment
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Fire Island Gem offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a 8-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. The apartment has access to a restaurant. The apartment also offers facilities for disabled guests. The spacious apartment is composed of 2 bedrooms, a dining area, a fully equipped kitchen, and 1 bathroom. Towels and bed linen are available in the apartment. The property has an outdoor dining area. Guests at the apartment will be able to enjoy activities in and around Ocean Bay Park, like cycling. The apartment has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from Fire Island Gem, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Wheelchair Accessible • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • View • Child Friendly • Security/Safety • Accessibility • Restaurant • Guest Services • Sports/Activities

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Clegg's Hotel
Hotel
478 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770, USA

Family-friendly hotel with free breakfast connected to a shopping center in Ocean Beach
A snack bar/deli, coffee/tea in a common area, and free use of bicycles are available at this hotel. Free continental breakfast, free WiFi in public areas, and a free manager's reception are also provided. Additionally, concierge services, a library, and free newspapers are onsite.
Clegg's Hotel offers 19 air-conditioned accommodations with complimentary newspapers and designer toiletries. These individually decorated and furnished accommodations include desk chairs. Beds feature premium bedding. A pillow menu is available. This Ocean Beach hotel provides complimentary wireless Internet access, with a speed of 50+ Mbps. Bathrooms include complimentary toiletries and hair dryers. Hypo-allergenic bedding, irons/ironing boards, and hair dryers can be requested. Housekeeping is provided daily.
Recreational amenities at the hotel include complimentary bicycles.

The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.

Guest Reviews:

- "We stayed one night and this hotel was awesome. First, they allow a 11:30 am check in which is rare. We were visiting friends so we dropped bags off and came back late night but it was convenient be able to do so. The room was immaculate and even though the bathrooms are shared, you get the full bathroom to yourself when you use it. The location is great just outside the ferry terminal. It’s very loud at night but we brought earplugs. Most importantly, staff are very friendly and held on to our bags until 2 pm the next day. They also offer coffee, fruits and pastry bites which was unexpected. In conclusion, well worth the money and I highly recommend. "

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a 4-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. Neguntatogue Park is 15 miles away and Green Park is 16 miles from the vacation home. The vacation home includes 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms with a bath, a seating area, and a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher. Towels and bed linen are offered in the vacation home. The property has an outdoor dining area. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Balcony/Terrace • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • View • Fireplace/Heating • Child Friendly • Restaurant • Security/Safety • Pet Friendly • Sports/Activities • Guest Services

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
The Palms Hotel Fire Island
Hotel
168 Cottage Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770, USA

Boardwalk/promenade hotel with free breakfast and a coffee shop
Along with a snack bar/deli, this smoke-free hotel has a coffee shop/cafe and free use of bicycles. Buffet breakfast is free. Additionally, concierge services, wedding services, and barbecue grills are onsite.
Change of towels is available on request.
The Palms Hotel Fire Island offers 42 air-conditioned accommodations with safes and complimentary bottled water. Beds feature down comforters. Flat-screen televisions come with satellite channels.

Bathrooms include showers, complimentary toiletries, and hair dryers. This Ocean Beach hotel provides complimentary wireless Internet access, with a speed of 25+ Mbps. Change of towels and change of bedsheets can be requested. A nightly turndown service is provided and housekeeping is offered daily.


Recreational amenities at the hotel include complimentary bicycles.

The recreational activities listed below are available either on site or nearby; fees may apply.

Guest Reviews:

- "3rd time staying." - "Nice place" - "The property is amazing and very equipped " - "Loved the location of my stay. Had a couple of hiccups with tv and toilet but it was addressed right away and hey , this was their opening weekend so no worries. I was moved to another room and all good. Staff was amazing, felt more like friends . I would definitely come back and I would refer them to friends. The ease of getting to and from the ferry was awesome! Check in/ out was great! Very accommodating and genuine. "

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Robbins Rest Retreat
House
Ocean Beach, NY, USA

A few steps from Ocean Beach in Ocean Beach, Robbins Rest Retreat offers accommodations with access to a sauna. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. The vacation home also offers facilities for disabled guests. Leading onto a balcony, the vacation home consists of 6 bedrooms. Offering a terrace with sea views, this vacation home also has a satellite flat-screen TV, a well-equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, an oven, and a microwave, as well as 1 bathroom with a walk-in shower and free toiletries. There's also a seating area and a fireplace. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Nikon Theater is 20 miles from the vacation home, while Jones Beach is 20 miles away.

Amenities:

Balcony/Terrace • View • Wheelchair Accessible • Sports/Activities • Pet Friendly • Guest Services • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Accessibility • Security/Safety • Restaurant • Wellness Facilities • Laundry

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
The Madison Fire Island Pines
House
22 Atlantic Walk, Sayville, NY, 11782, USA

While you're here, you can enjoy all the comforts of home and more, including a heated pool and free WiFi, as well as a garden and a rooftop terrace.

Guest Reviews:

- "Very relaxed environment. Will definitely visit again. " - "We had such an awesome weekend here. The guesthouse is so nice, neat and organized. Thank you to all the staff for your hospitality. You guys made us feel so welcome." - "Best part about the trip was Angela! Who hosted the stay." - "Very cozy stay, friendly staff and we met nice people at the hotel. Beautiful open architecture of the building and great amenities (common kitchen area and atrium style lobby). "

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
15 Seneca
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

15 Seneca is located in Ocean Bay Park, just a 2-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. The vacation home also offers facilities for disabled guests. The air-conditioned vacation home consists of 3 bedrooms, a living room, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and a coffee machine, and 2 bathrooms with a hot tub and a hair dryer. Towels and bed linen are featured in the vacation home. There's also a seating area and a fireplace. The vacation home also offers an outdoor swimming pool and a hot tub for guests to relax in. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from 15 Seneca, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles away.

Amenities:

Wellness Facilities • Restaurant • Guest Services • Fireplace/Heating • Hot Tub • Balcony/Terrace • Pet Friendly • Laundry • Air Conditioner • Sports/Activities • Security/Safety • Wheelchair Accessible

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Beach front 2-bedroom - Fire Island Pines - 30 day min. stay
Condo
Sayville, New York, USA

Get away to one of the worlds most idealic gay beachfront resort towns. There's no place quite like Fire Island Pines and renting your own charming 2 bedroom/2 bath oceanfront co-op for 30 days will make you wish it will last forever. You'll be amazed by the splendor of the natural surroundings - the sounds and sights. sunshine, moonlit nights, the surf, birds, butterflies, deer and beautiful people will enchant you. And, if you're night owl, the never ending program of entertainment and partying in town (just a short walk away) will keep you smiling. Includes electric, wifi, central A/C. 30 day minimum stay - doesn't have to be consecutive nights. For example: you may book 2 weeks in July, 1 week in August and 1 week in September or October.

Amenities:

Pet Friendly • Laundry • Bedding/Linens • Fireplace/Heating • Internet • Child Friendly • Security/Safety • Air Conditioner

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
195 Wilmot Road
House
Ocean Beach, NY, USA

195 Wilmot Road offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, a 5-minute walk from Ocean Beach. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. Opening onto a balcony, the vacation home consists of 3 bedrooms. Providing a terrace, this vacation home also offers a flat-screen TV, a well-equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, an oven, and a microwave, as well as 2 bathrooms with a walk-in shower and free toiletries. The property has an outdoor dining area. Guests at the vacation home will be able to enjoy activities in and around Ocean Beach, like cycling. A children's playground is also available for guests at 195 Wilmot Road.

Amenities:

Restaurant • Security/Safety • Child Friendly • Balcony/Terrace • Guest Services • View • Sports/Activities • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Ocean Beach Bayview Cottage
House
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

This cozy cottage is located just one house away from the Great South Bay, and it's only a 2-minute walk to the bay swimming area, playground and the best dining and shopping spots in town. The house is sunny and bright, with hardwood floors. The kitchen is open-concept and well-equipped, with quartzite stone counters and a breakfast bar. There's a dining area that can comfortably seat six people. The two cozy bedrooms are air-conditioned and come with queen beds and beautiful linens. The living room's loveseat can also be converted into a twin bed.
The private wrap-around deck is perfect for dining out, with a gas BBQ and two separate areas to enjoy meals, whether you prefer dining under the stars or beneath shady market umbrellas. There are comfy lounge chairs for sunning, and a spacious outdoor shower to rinse off after a day at the beach. Modern amenities like FIOS Wireless Internet and a flat-screen HD TV with premium channels are provided.

This peaceful haven has everything you need to feel at home. All you need to bring is your toothbrush and bathing suit. Beach towels, beach chairs, beach umbrellas, and a wagon are also provided, making this home the perfect place to create new vacation memories. Life here is easy, convenient, and fun!

AMENITIES HIGHLIGHTS
*Fully Equipped Kitchen
*Open Living/Dining/Kitchen Layout
*Stainless Steel Gas Grill
*Picnic Tables and Market Umbrellas
*Outdoor Shower
*2 Bicycles
*Large Wagon
*Cooler
*Beach Chairs and Umbrellas
*Large Washer and Dryer
*Space Heaters~No Central Heating
Guests have private access to the entire house.
Ocean Beach is the unofficial capital of Fire Island and has the greatest number of restaurants and shops. Overflowing with a small-town charm reminiscent of a simpler time, main street walks are lined with mom-and-pop markets and boutiques. Local children sell painted shell souvenirs out of red wagons. Just outside of town, Ocean Beach walkways are lined with a mix of traditional summer cottages and modern houses. The house is perfectly located setback fromthe bay near the town and all that the town offers. Close to the life-guarded swimming area and waterfront playground with plenty of fun things for the kids to play on while you relax on one of the many benches or Gazebo, and enjoy the most spectacular view.
We are pet friendly andlove dogs, but you MUST ask before booking, as sometimes guests who are very allergic have booked after you and we need to ensure that we provide a safe space for them, too. Please provide information such as age, breed, weight, if it is house-trained, or crate-trained, how much barking to expect and for how long it will be left alone at a time.
This is a Beach House. There is no Central Heating but Space Heaters are provided, if there is a chill.
Above all else, we value your privacy and are happy with whatever level of interaction you wish.
No cars are permitted, so water taxis, walking and biking are the best ways to navigate the island.

Guest Reviews:

- "Wonderful stay at this cottage. Close to all. Joe and Diane are wonderful people and make you feel like your coming home." - "The house was just as advertise clean and comfortable The location was great near the ferry and the town I would stay here again" - "The house was cute with a great location. Diane (owner) met us at the dock - making the location easy to find. Diane was extremely helpful and responsive. Helped with bikes and all other needs. The house provided many amenities, including washer/dryer - convenient outside shower (also full bath inside) - grill with propane."

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
37 Ocean Bay Blvd
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

37 Ocean Bay Blvd offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a few steps from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. This beachfront property offers access to a patio. The vacation home also offers facilities for disabled guests. Providing access to a balcony, the vacation home consists of 4 bedrooms. Offering a terrace with sea views, this vacation home also features a flat-screen TV, a well-equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, an oven, and a microwave, as well as 2 bathrooms with a bath and a hair dryer. The property has an outdoor dining area. Guests may eat at the on-site restaurant. Guests at the vacation home will be able to enjoy activities in and around Ocean Bay Park, like cycling. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from 37 Ocean Bay Blvd, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Guest Services • Balcony/Terrace • Restaurant • Sports/Activities • Laundry • Ocean View • Security/Safety • View • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Fireplace/Heating • Accessibility • Oceanfront

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with deck & gas grill
Condo
Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA

The Surfcomber Unit 1

Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired dates and click 'Book Now!'

Perfect for a romantic escapade with your significant other, this condo located in the heart of Ocean Bay Park and accessible only by ferry is ready to be your home away from home! You can reach the ferry terminal in Bay Shore after a 15-minute drive from Long Island MacArthur Airport, meaning you'll be enjoying your sandy paradise in no time. Paid parking is available at 99 Maple Ave. on the right for those arriving at the ferry terminal by car. As soon as you step inside, you'll be greeted by a simple yet sunny interior that will delight you immediately. Drop your bags and kick your feet up in the living area, or step outside to the private gated deck and spend your evening relaxing. When you return from the beach, the outdoor shower will be ready to help you rinse off the sand. Then, whenever hunger strikes, you can surprise your friends with a savory homemade meal prepared in the well-equipped kitchen, and if you'd like to step it up a notch, the gas grill available is a great option.

This home is only 1.5 blocks from the beach and the Atlantic Ocean, as well as mere steps from Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop shop for watersports lessons and parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals. Seaview is a short five-minute walk away, while Ocean Beach is only a mile from you, giving you even more options while out and about. Spend hot summer days at Sunken Forest a 23-minute walk away, where you can enjoy some shade and take a ranger-led walk through the trees and dunes. After a gorgeous day on the sand, take your pick from the dozens of local restaurants to sate your appetite. Steps away in the neighborhood is Schooner's Inn, a restaurant and bar near the ferry while Flynn's Fire Island is a two-minute walk from you. Dino's on the Bay deli and Island Pantry are a bit further, but well worth the five-minute walk. Island Mermaid and Hideaway are also great dining options one mile away in Ocean Beach. Traveling five miles will take you to the Fire Island Lighthouse, where you can learn about the history of Fire Island and take a tour of the tower.

The other two homes on the property, Unit 2 and Unit 3, are available to rent as well; all three condos can be rented together as The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home.

Things to Know
Check-in time: 4:00 p.m.
Check-out time: 10:00 a.m.
All guests shall abide by Vacasa’s good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m.
No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.
This home has a strict age limit that is monitored for every stay. All members of your party need to be 25 years or older unless they are children accompanied by a parent or legal guardian.
Vacasa is a registered New York State sales tax vendor. And if Vacasa is the merchant of record will collect sales tax and applicable unit fees on all sales of short-term rental unit occupancy within New York State that it facilitates.

If you are bringing a dog on your trip, the pet fee is already included in your quote when selecting ‘Yes’ to pets. No more dogs are allowed.
Parking notes: No parking available.

Security camera details: There are active security cameras around the exterior of this property.

Dock details: Marina is next to Flynn's restaurant.

Please note: this home resides in a noise-sensitive area and the owners participate in our Good Neighbor protection program. Our smart home technology will alert our team if excessive decibel or occupancy levels are detected, allowing us to reach out directly with a reminder of maximum occupancy and quiet hours. This technology is privacy compliant, and only monitors the presence of decibels and devices-not any personal conversation or information. Thank you for supporting our efforts to be good neighbors!

Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a nightly damage waiver fee, plus tax if applicable (the “Damage Waiver”). (A discount may be applied for stays of 28 nights or longer, if permitted.) The Damage Waiver covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. The Damage Waiver fee eliminates the need for a traditional security deposit.
More information can be downloaded from the "Rental Agreement" on the checkout page.

Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.

Guest Reviews:

- "This unit is perfect for a quick get away and relaxing weekend. Great location, perfect for walking around the area and close to the beach." - "Clean, comfortable, and colorful with the fun yellow accents. We are a family of four originally from NYC and we like cozy so the fact that the kitchen and deck are small was fine with us. The photos are a good representation which I always appreciate. Great location!" - "It’s our fourth year in a row…and we’ll be back."

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Casa de Zeus
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Casa de Zeus offers accommodations in Ocean Bay Park, a 2-minute walk from Ocean Beach. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. This vacation home includes 2 bedrooms, a living room and a flat-screen TV, an equipped kitchen with a dining area, and 1 bathroom with a bath and a washing machine. Towels and bed linen are offered in the vacation home. The property has an outdoor dining area. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors.

Amenities:

Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Fireplace/Heating • Pet Friendly • Balcony/Terrace • Child Friendly • Laundry • Restaurant • Sports/Activities • Security/Safety

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with Rooftop Deck
Condo
Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA

The Surfcomber Unit 2

Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired dates and click 'Book Now!'

Welcome to the condo that will make your wishes for a stress-free vacation come true! Its prime location in the heart of the charming Ocean Bay Park and the fact it's accessible only by ferry will surely help you relax and leave your worries at the door. You can reach the ferry terminal in Bay Shore after a 15-minute drive from Long Island MacArthur Airport, meaning you'll be enjoying your sandy paradise in no time. Paid parking is available at 99 Maple Ave. on the right for those arriving at the ferry terminal by car.

When you arrive, what's really going to help you unwind is the gorgeous rooftop deck equipped with an outdoor dining area with all new and dedicated beach chairs and umbrellas. We can't even think of a better place to relax and sunbathe. This retreat is all about comfort; the bedroom features a bed with a brand-new memory foam mattress. Stream your favorite TV shows, prepare savory snacks in the well-equipped kitchen, and snuggle up on the couch to start your movie night.

This home is only 1.5 blocks from the beach and the Atlantic Ocean, as well as mere steps from Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop shop for watersports lessons and parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals. Seaview is a short five-minute walk away, while Ocean Beach is only a mile from you, giving you even more options while out and about. Spend hot summer days at Sunken Forest a 23-minute walk away, where you can enjoy some shade and take a ranger-led walk through the trees and dunes. After a gorgeous day on the sand, take your pick from the dozens of local restaurants to sate your appetite. Steps away in the neighborhood is Schooner's Inn, a restaurant and bar near the ferry while Flynn's Fire Island is a two-minute walk from you. Dino's on the Bay deli and Island Pantry are a bit further, but well worth the five-minute walk. Island Mermaid and Hideaway are also great dining options one mile away in Ocean Beach. Traveling five miles will take you to the Fire Island Lighthouse, where you can learn about the history of Fire Island and take a tour of the tower.

The other two apartments on the property, Unit 1 and Unit 3, are available to rent as well; all three apartments can be rented together as the Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home.

Things to Know
Check-in time: 4:00 p.m.
Check-out time: 10:00 a.m.
All guests shall abide by Vacasa’s good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m.
No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.
This home has a strict age limit that is monitored for every stay. All members of your party need to be 25 years or older unless they are children accompanied by a parent or legal guardian.
Vacasa is a registered New York State sales tax vendor. And if Vacasa is the merchant of record will collect sales tax and applicable unit fees on all sales of short-term rental unit occupancy within New York State that it facilitates.

If you are bringing a dog on your trip, the pet fee is already included in your quote when selecting ‘Yes’ to pets. No more dogs are allowed.
Parking notes: No parking available.

Security camera details: Exterior on the whole property.

Please note: this home resides in a noise-sensitive area and the owners participate in our Good Neighbor protection program. Our smart home technology will alert our team if excessive decibel or occupancy levels are detected, allowing us to reach out directly with a reminder of maximum occupancy and quiet hours. This technology is privacy compliant, and only monitors the presence of decibels and devices-not any personal conversation or information. Thank you for supporting our efforts to be good neighbors!

Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a nightly damage waiver fee, plus tax if applicable (the “Damage Waiver”). (A discount may be applied for stays of 28 nights or longer, if permitted.) The Damage Waiver covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. The Damage Waiver fee eliminates the need for a traditional security deposit.
More information can be downloaded from the "Rental Agreement" on the checkout page.

Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.

Guest Reviews:

- "We loved the upper deck, outdoor shower, and central AC. Peaceful and quiet but close enough to Ocean Beach for nightlife and shops." - "Great location, closer to the bayside but the ocean is right down the block (3min walk).. easy access, gated and just as photos portrayed. The walls are thin between unit one and two so you would hear children, or anyone being loud in the morning if there is a concern for sleeping in." - "We loved this space for us and our 2 young kids. Kitchen to cook meals, BBQ, awesome rooftop terrace and adorable decor. There are 3 units total and this one suited our needs. 2 blocks from the beach and less than a block from the ferry. 2 restaurants close by with cool beach vibes and kid friendly."

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Paradiso
House
Ocean Beach, NY, USA

Paradiso is located in Ocean Beach, just a 5-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. The vacation home also offers facilities for disabled guests. Providing a patio with pool views, this vacation home also provides guests with a satellite flat-screen TV, a well-equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, an oven, and a microwave, as well as 2 bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a hair dryer. The property has an outdoor dining area. For guests with children, the vacation home provides a baby safety gate and a children's playground. Guests at Paradiso can enjoy cycling nearby, or make the most of the outdoor pool. Jones Beach is 20 miles from the accommodation, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles away.

Amenities:

Balcony/Terrace • Pet Friendly • Security/Safety • Wheelchair Accessible • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Child Friendly • Restaurant • Accessibility • View • Guest Services • Laundry • Sports/Activities

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
2 Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park, walk to beach and entertainment
House
Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA

The Surfcomber Unit 3

Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired dates and click 'Book Now!'

Experience the beach getaway of a lifetime with your nearest and dearest at this condo in the heart of Fire Island's Ocean Bay Park! This kid-friendly retreat is accessible only by ferry and features two levels full of comfort and convenient amenities. You can reach the ferry terminal in Bay Shore after a 15-minute drive from Long Island MacArthur Airport, meaning you'll be enjoying your sandy paradise in no time. Paid parking is available at 99 Maple Ave. on the right for those arriving at the ferry terminal by car. Walk to the beach each morning, come home to grill and relax on the deck, and take leisurely rides around town on one of the provided bikes. The well-equipped kitchen will also make cooking a breeze; make sure to buy some groceries and goodies at the nearby Ocean Bay Park Market and surprise your guests with savory, full-course meals or quick beach snacks. Once mealtime is over, unwind on the deck that comes equipped with all-new beach chairs and umbrellas, or head back inside to snuggle up on the sofa and watch a fun movie on the smart TV with a refreshing beverage in hand. This retreat also boasts a convenient washer/dryer combo that will allow you to pack light and make space for souvenirs. The king bed features a brand-new memory foam mattress, ensuring a blissful night's rest.

This home is only 1.5 blocks from the beach and the Atlantic Ocean, as well as mere steps from Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop shop for watersports lessons and parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals. Seaview is a short five-minute walk away, while Ocean Beach is only a mile from you, giving you even more options while out and about. Spend hot summer days at Sunken Forest a 23-minute walk away, where you can enjoy some shade and take a ranger-led walk through the trees and dunes. After a gorgeous day on the sand, take your pick from the dozens of local restaurants to sate your appetite. Steps away in the neighborhood is Schooner's Inn, a restaurant and bar near the ferry while Flynn's Fire Island is a two-minute walk from you. Dino's on the Bay deli and Island Pantry are a bit further, but well worth the five-minute walk. Island Mermaid and Hideaway are also great dining options one mile away in Ocean Beach. Traveling five miles will take you to the Fire Island Lighthouse, where you can learn about the history of Fire Island and take a tour of the tower.

The other two apartments on the property, Unit 1 and Unit 2, are available to rent as well; all three apartments can be rented together as The Surfcomber Multi-Residence Home.

Things to Know
Check-in time: 4:00 p.m.
Check-out time: 10:00 a.m.
All guests shall abide by Vacasa’s good neighbor policy and shall not engage in illegal activity. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m.
No smoking is permitted anywhere on the premises.
This home has a strict age limit that is monitored for every stay. All members of your party need to be 25 years or older unless they are children accompanied by a parent or legal guardian.
Vacasa is a registered New York State sales tax vendor. And if Vacasa is the merchant of record will collect sales tax and applicable unit fees on all sales of short-term rental unit occupancy within New York State that it facilitates.

If you are bringing a dog on your trip, the pet fee is already included in your quote when selecting ‘Yes’ to pets. No more dogs are allowed.
Parking notes: No parking available.

This rental is located on floor 1.

Security camera details: Exterior all around the property

Please note: this home resides in a noise-sensitive area and the owners participate in our Good Neighbor protection program. Our smart home technology will alert our team if excessive decibel or occupancy levels are detected, allowing us to reach out directly with a reminder of maximum occupancy and quiet hours. This technology is privacy compliant, and only monitors the presence of decibels and devices-not any personal conversation or information. Thank you for supporting our efforts to be good neighbors!

Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a nightly damage waiver fee, plus tax if applicable (the “Damage Waiver”). (A discount may be applied for stays of 28 nights or longer, if permitted.) The Damage Waiver covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. The Damage Waiver fee eliminates the need for a traditional security deposit.
More information can be downloaded from the "Rental Agreement" on the checkout page.

Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a great time the property looked like the picture minor hiccups" - "My family rented the unit for two nights while staying at the beach. Great beach access and great l place to see. Shopping eating and night life with in walking distance" - "This Vacasa home was amazing! The size is perfect for families or groups of friends, and the all white interior really gives that classic Fire Island feel. My family had a relaxing 2 night stay. Highly recommend renting the bikes and driving around Ocean Pay Park, Seaview and Ocean Beach."

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
Poolside Chic by the Sea
House
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Poolside Chic by the Sea is located in Ocean Bay Park, just a 2-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater. With sea views, this accommodation provides a swimming pool. Neguntatogue Park is 15 miles from the vacation home and Green Park is 16 miles away. The air-conditioned vacation home also features a flat-screen TV, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher, a seating area, washing machine, and 2 bathrooms with a walk-in shower. The property has an outdoor dining area. Guests are welcome to eat at the on-site restaurant. Guests at the vacation home will be able to enjoy activities in and around Ocean Bay Park, like cycling. The vacation home has a picnic area where you can spend the day outdoors. Jones Beach is 20 miles from Poolside Chic by the Sea, while Bergen Point County Golf Course is 14 miles from the property.

Amenities:

Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Security/Safety • Balcony/Terrace • Fireplace/Heating • Air Conditioner • Pool • Laundry • Sports/Activities • Restaurant • Guest Services • View • Child Friendly

Vacation Rentals in Fire Island
🌞New Listing! Ocean View Retreat!🌞
House
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Spectacular two bedroom cottage with Ocean Views! Fall asleep to the sound of crashing waves and wake up every morning to a Fire Island sunrise. Steps from the beach, close to town, located in the exclusive Corneille Estates community. Recently updated, with everything you'll need including an outdoor shower, wifi, smart TV, kitchen amenities, towels, sheets, blankets, and more. Truly outstanding value, come enjoy the perfect Fire Island experience!!

Guest Reviews:

- "Cozy retreat with fabulous views from living room and spectacular deck. Such easy access to ocean! Especially loved: fast cooling AC, roomy outdoor shower, high ceilings and skylight made living area bright and open. Occasional struggle with wifi (host very helpful!)" - "We loved it! The house was nicer than we expected and the view was amazing." - "Cute, clean beachfront cottage. Easy checking. Owner easy to communicate with. Wonderful long weekend with friends."

Fire Island Family Friendly Vacation rentals

Fire Island Pet Friendly Vacation rentals

Fire Island Vacation rentals with Entertainment

Fire Island Vacation rentals with Parking

Fire Island Vacation-Rentals on the Map

Compare the Best Vacation-Rentals in Fire Island – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Property Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
Huron Hideaway Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 282 4.0 9.3 3 Click here
Grove Hotel 1 Ocean Walk, Cherry Grove, Sayville, NY, 11782, USA 130 3.0 9.4 427 Click here
Fire Island Gem Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 456 4.0 9.0 2 Click here
Clegg's Hotel 478 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770, USA 271 3.0 8.0 195 Click here
Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 1547 4.0 9.5 2 Click here
The Palms Hotel Fire Island 168 Cottage Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770, USA 347 3.0 7.8 176 Click here
Robbins Rest Retreat Ocean Beach, NY, USA 1706 4.0 8.5 2 Click here
The Madison Fire Island Pines 22 Atlantic Walk, Sayville, NY, 11782, USA 423 3.0 8.8 45 Click here
15 Seneca Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 1871 4.0 10.0 2 Click here
Beach front 2-bedroom - Fire Island Pines - 30 day min. stay Sayville, New York, USA 1020 2.0 1 Click here
195 Wilmot Road Ocean Beach, NY, USA 183 4.0 7.0 1 Click here
Ocean Beach Bayview Cottage Ocean Beach, New York, USA 627 10.0 62 Click here
37 Ocean Bay Blvd Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 547 4.0 4.0 1 Click here
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with deck & gas grill Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA 535 9.2 38 Click here
Casa de Zeus Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 665 4.0 5.0 1 Click here
One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with Rooftop Deck Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA 503 9.0 32 Click here
Paradiso Ocean Beach, NY, USA 2095 4.0 10.0 1 Click here
2 Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park, walk to beach and entertainment Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA 765 8.6 32 Click here
Poolside Chic by the Sea Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 2958 4.0 5.0 1 Click here
🌞New Listing! Ocean View Retreat!🌞 Ocean Beach, New York, USA 778 9.2 27 Click here

Note: The prices for each Vacation-Rentals in Fire Island do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Vacation rentals in Fire Island that include a pool include:

  • Grove Hotel.- Review Count: 427, Rating: 9.4
  • Clegg's Hotel.- Review Count: 195, Rating: 8.0
  • The Madison Fire Island Pines.- Review Count: 45, Rating: 8.8

Vacation rentals in Fire Island offering shuttle or transport options include:

  • Grove Hotel.- Review Count: 427, Rating: 9.4
  • Clegg's Hotel.- Review Count: 195, Rating: 8.0

Family-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island include:

  • Huron Hideaway.- Review Count: 3, Rating: 9.3
  • Fire Island Gem.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 9.0
  • Clegg's Hotel.- Review Count: 195, Rating: 8.0

Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Fire Island include:

  • Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 9.5
  • Robbins Rest Retreat.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 8.5
  • 15 Seneca.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0

Vacation rentals in Fire Island that include breakfast options include:

  • Clegg's Hotel.- Review Count: 195, Rating: 8.0
  • The Palms Hotel Fire Island.- Review Count: 176, Rating: 7.8
  • The Madison Fire Island Pines.- Review Count: 45, Rating: 8.8

Vacation rentals in Fire Island with private or on-site parking include:

  • One Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park with deck & gas grill.- Review Count: 38, Rating: 9.2
  • 2 Bedroom Apt. in Ocean Bay Park, walk to beach and entertainment.- Review Count: 32, Rating: 8.6
  • FireIslandEscape - Fun, sun and relaxation awaits you!.- Review Count: 20, Rating: 10.0

Some of the best Vacation Rentals in Fire Island are:

  • Huron Hideaway.- Review Count: 3, Rating: 9.3
  • Fire Island Gem.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 9.0
  • Cayuga Street Sunshine Retreat.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 9.5

Some of the popular Vacation Rentals in Fire Island are:

  • Grove Hotel.- Review Count: 427, Rating: 9.4
  • Clegg's Hotel.- Review Count: 195, Rating: 8.0
  • The Palms Hotel Fire Island.- Review Count: 176, Rating: 7.8