Charming Bed and Breakfasts and Inns in Fire Island, NY

Mod 8 / private bath & deck
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

Mod 8 is a chic rustic cabin room a Horace Gifford designed compound. The verdant property is both secluded & convenient. The 1965 mid-century bedroom is 70 sq. ft. has a full bed. There is also a private compact 1/2 bath & a private outdoor shower. The space is stylish with an Eames chair & coatrack and a Arne Jacobsen chair.There is also a 40 sq. ft. private deck area. 3 night minimum holidays & 2 weekend.

Hotel tax included.

The space
PLEASE READ THE FOLLOWING

Our rooms are extremely well priced compared to our competition but the Pines is very expensive because it's seasonal & very close to NYC.

1. Or rooms are rustic not slick.
2. We are not a luxury hotel just a guest house.
3. The photos make the very small room seem larger.
4. There is access to a communal stove & outdoor prep area.

Amenities:

Wifi • Pets allowed • Smoke alarm • Air conditioning • Essentials

Newly Renovated Studio for 2 in Cherry Grove, FI
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

This unique place has a style all its own.
Recently Renovated Spacious Studio for 2 ppl only a few steps from the beach at Dune Point Guesthouse.
Located in Cherry Grove, Fire Island. Only accessible by Ferry!
Adults Only Resort!

Fully equipped kitchen, small fridge, table and chairs; perfect for a few days stay, BBQ, cook, enjoy the beach. There is a common ocean deck on the property with direct access to the beach for all the guests to enjoy.

Amenities:

Hair dryer • Outdoor shower • Conditioner • Cleaning products • Shampoo • Hot water • Hangers • Body soap • Essentials • Bed linens

One Bedroom Cottage in Cherry Grove
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

A one bedroom in a recently renovated traditional cottage in Cherry Grove, a gay beach resort in the middle of a national park with some of the most beautiful beaches in the northeast. Five minutes away from the beach and near downtown bars and restaurants.

The space
Tweedle Dum is part of the historic Tweedles cottage in Cherry Grove. It has one full bedroom with a queen size bed, living room with eating area, equipped kitchen and bathroom with glass shower. Separate entrance with a private deck furnished with a table, chairs, a bench, and a new gas grill. Very quiet and set up for a relaxing vacation.

Guest access
Separate entrance from main house, own deck and facilities.

Other things to note
We have a no pet policy.

Amenities:

Essentials • Books and reading material • Malin+Goetz body soap • Garden view • Hair dryer • Central air conditioning • Room-darkening shades • Bed linens • Hangers • Hot water

Fire Island Pines Modern Studio w/Full Kitchenette
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

Private studio close to Fire Island Pines harbor and beach. The studio has 2 Twin XL beds (configured either 2 twin XL beds or configured into king when pushed together), a kitchenette, dishwasher, dining table for 2, oversized bathroom, outdoor shower.
Strict maximum of 2 guest policy, NO EXCEPTIONS!

Other things to note
Please let us know how you would like the beds configured, as two twin beds or as a king. We need 24-48 hours notice to accommodate request.

Amenities:

Outdoor shower • Room-darkening shades • TV with standard cable • Garden view • Cleaning products • Hair dryer • Iron • Ethernet connection • Essentials • AC - split type ductless system

Gorgeous 2 bedroom in Cherry Grove, Fire Island
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The space
Private deck overlooking the bay. Two bedrooms, full kitchen, dishwasher, AC in every room. Cable and internet. Full living room space with two couches.

Amenities:

Bed linens • Conditioner • Dryer • Shampoo • Hair dryer • Hot water • Hangers • Body soap • Essentials • Washer

CEDAR DUNES - Forest Bedroom
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

This spacious room has two full beds, its own private bathroom, desk area and an extra deep closet. Heating and A/C is easily controlled in the room. This is one of four other rental bedrooms in the house (which can hold a total of 8 guests max.) For parties more than 2 people, each room will need to be booked separately.

The space
CENTRALLY located, this newly renovated cottage is just minutes away from the harbor and ocean. With five bedrooms total (four of them being rentals), the house consists of people who like to relax and enjoy themselves. Amenities include: 70" HDTV with Cable, high-speed wireless internet access, brand new pool, outdoor shower, and powerful 6-person jacuzzi!

Please note: there's no smoking allowed in the house or on the property. This is not a party house. Other than that, please feel free to relax and enjoy!

Guest access
The common areas include: kitchen, dining room, living room, community center, outdoor deck which includes pool, hot tub, grill, and outdoor shower.

During your stay
The house is similar to a B&B where I (the owner) am usually there most of the time. It's a big house, and my bedroom/studio is upstairs where I tend to be immersed in my artwork (or be at the beach:)

Amenities:

Clothing storage • Essentials • Dryer • Extra pillows and blankets • Bed linens • Hangers • Room-darkening shades • Washer • Hot water • Iron

Live-Work Space Cabana 2
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

Spacious room in charming guesthouse. Located 3 minute walk from the Ferry and Pantry. Huge property with pool hot tub sauna and lots of outdoor spaces

The space
Private room in the guest house of a wonderful Pines home. Queen size bed. AC TV Wi-Fi Sonos pool hot tub outdoor cedar sauna large deck and living area. Has a kitchen which is shared with the other cabana room as well as 1.5 bathrooms. Three minutes from the center of the Pines

Guest access
guest have access to the entire property including: pool hot tub and sauna as well as grills and all outdoor areas. Guest may use the living and dining areas of the main house.

Other things to note
The Pines is gay. GA Y! Pines is known for many men running around in heat. This house is not appropriate for children young adults and teens tweens and most families

1 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island Pines

One bedroom, one bathroom private poolside suite in Fire Island Pines with a large private living room and kitchen. Private entrance with a view of the pool. Three minute walk from the harbor and three minute walk to the beach. Queen bed. The bathroom has a walk-in shower and Toto washlet. Shared hot tub, 91 degree heated pool, and outdoor shower. Shared roof deck with a 360 degrees view of the Pines. Small gym beneath the house. New construction (2018).

Amenities:

Shower gel • Cleaning products • Hot water • Shampoo • Body soap • Essentials • Conditioner • Bidet • Outdoor shower • Hair dryer

Penthouse Bedroom B
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Penthouse Room B is one of The Madison's largest and most beautiful bedrooms. Enter through a private hallway, which opens onto a sun-drenched room with 12-foot ceilings. The room overlooks the pool, with glass doors providing access to a Juliette balcony. It features a private bathroom, custom wood floors, AC, LED TV and broadband internet.

Amenities:

Bed linens • Paid parking off premises • Sun loungers • Pets allowed • Patio or balcony • Backyard • Breakfast • Wifi • Pool view

Dexter Bedroom A
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Dexter Room A is the largest bedroom in the main house. It has high ceilings, a private bath, and floor-to-ceiling windows looking down upon a beautiful back garden. Located on the second floor, it is one of the most private rooms in the house. The room has a large LED flat screen TV, AC and high-speed internet.

Amenities:

Patio or balcony • Paid parking off premises • Sun loungers • Hot water • Dedicated workspace • Hair dryer • Wifi • Garden view • Backyard • Bed linens

Madison Bedroom B
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Madison Room B is one of our smaller bedrooms, located in the main house, with a private bathroom, A/C, flat-screen television and hi-speed internet.

Amenities:

Hair dryer • Bed linens • Iron • Paid parking off premises • Backyard • Dedicated workspace • Wifi • Sun loungers • TV • Patio or balcony

Dexter Bedroom B
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Dexter Room B is on the second floor of the main house, with high ceilings, private bath, AC and sunlight splashing in from oversized glass doors leading onto the upper deck.

Amenities:

Paid parking off premises • Breakfast • Patio or balcony • Pool view • Backyard • Wifi • Pets allowed • Sun loungers • Bed linens

Madison Bedroom A
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Madison Room A is a medium-sized room located in the main house, with glass doors opening to the back garden. Private bathroom, a/c, flat-screen television and free broadband internet.

Amenities:

Dedicated workspace • Garden view • Hot water • Hair dryer • Patio or balcony • Wifi • Sun loungers • Bed linens • Backyard • Paid parking off premises

Penthouse Bedroom A
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Penthouse Room A is The Madison's largest and most beautiful bedroom. It's a sun-drenched room with 12-foot ceilings and floor to ceiling glass walls overlooking the pool, with doors providing access to a Juliette balcony. It features a modern, private bathroom, AC, custom wood floors, broadband internet and large LED TV.

Amenities:

Backyard • Paid parking off premises • Sun loungers • Wifi • Pool view • Breakfast • Bed linens • Pets allowed • Patio or balcony

Single room-Private Bathroom-Standard-Madison Bedr
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
Madison Room C is the smallest at The Madison and is double occupancy.

It has a private entrance on the pool deck and another leading to the living room.

It has a queen-sized bed, private bathroom, free broadband internet and flat-screen TV.

Amenities:

Sun loungers • Backyard • Hair dryer • Paid parking off premises • Wifi • TV • Bed linens • Patio or balcony • Iron • Dedicated workspace

Garden Bedroom A
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

The Madison Fire Island Pines is the most acclaimed guest house in this internationally-famous gay community. Travel & Leisure recommends it as the best place to stay in the Pines. There’s a grand deck, a huge pool, modern, light-filled rooms (all with private baths), and a roof deck with panoramic views. The location is terrific: it's just a minute's walk to the beach and the harbor. The atmosphere is laid-back and friendly, and the house itself is spectacular. Stay for a week or a weekend.

The space
The modern Garden Rooms are located pool-side, with a wall of glass facing the pool. They are beautiful and modern cabana-style bedrooms, with custom wood floors, modern private bath, AC, LED TV's and broadband internet.

Amenities:

Dedicated workspace • Hair dryer • Sun loungers • Patio or balcony • Backyard • Wifi • Paid parking off premises • Hot water • Bed linens • Pool view

2 BR Private Poolside Suite Best Location FI Pines
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island

Two bedroom, one bathroom private poolside suite in Fire Island Pines with a large private living room and kitchen. Private entrance with a view of the pool. Three minute walk from the harbor and three minute walk to the beach. One bedroom has a queen bed, the other a bunk bed. The bathroom has a walk-in shower and Toto washlet. Shared hot tub, 91 degree heated pool, and outdoor shower. Shared roof deck with a 360 degrees view of the Pines. Small gym beneath the house. New construction (2018).

Other things to note
We request a minimum three-night stay, either Thursday - Sunday or Friday - Monday. For the following holiday weekends, we have a four-night minimum: 4th of July, August 2 Pines Party Weekend).

Amenities:

Hangers • Extra pillows and blankets • Hair dryer • Cleaning products • Hot water • Outdoor shower • Bidet • Essentials • Bed linens • Shower gel

3 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen
Bed & Breakfast
Fire Island Pines

This space consists of two private spaces in the same home: 1) a 2-BR, 1 bathroom private poolside suite with a large private living room + kitchen, & 2) a 1-BR private room above the suite with its own private bathroom. Both spaces have private entrances. Three minute walk from the harbor & 3 minute walk to the beach. BR1: queen bed; BR 2: bunk beds, BR3: king bed. Walk-in showers & Toto washlets. Shared hot tub, heated pool, outdoor shower, roof deck, small gym. New construction (2018).

Amenities:

Conditioner • Cleaning products • Hot water • Outdoor shower • Shower gel • Body soap • Bidet • Hair dryer • Shampoo • Essentials

Fire Island Bed-And-Breakfast on the Map

Compare the Best Bed-And-Breakfast in Fire Island – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Property Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
Mod 8 / private bath & deck Fire Island 200 9.52 1 Click here
Newly Renovated Studio for 2 in Cherry Grove, FI Fire Island 225 9.86 1 Click here
One Bedroom Cottage in Cherry Grove Fire Island 250 9.84 1 Click here
Fire Island Pines Modern Studio w/Full Kitchenette Fire Island 400 9.8 1 Click here
Gorgeous 2 bedroom in Cherry Grove, Fire Island Fire Island 400 9.0 1 Click here
CEDAR DUNES - Forest Bedroom Fire Island 400 9.84 1 Click here
Live-Work Space Cabana 2 Fire Island 420 10.0 1 Click here
1 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen Fire Island Pines 599 10.0 1 Click here
Penthouse Bedroom B Fire Island 885 1 Click here
Dexter Bedroom A Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
Madison Bedroom B Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
Dexter Bedroom B Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
Madison Bedroom A Fire Island 885 9.34 1 Click here
Penthouse Bedroom A Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
Single room-Private Bathroom-Standard-Madison Bedr Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
Garden Bedroom A Fire Island 885 10.0 1 Click here
2 BR Private Poolside Suite Best Location FI Pines Fire Island 1998 10.0 1 Click here
3 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen Fire Island Pines 2399 1 Click here

Note: The prices for each Bed-And-Breakfast in Fire Island do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Bed and breakfast stays in Fire Island that offer a pool include:

  • 1 BR Private Suite w/Private Living Room & Kitchen.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 10.0
  • Penthouse Bedroom B.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • Dexter Bedroom B.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 10.0

Bed and breakfast stays in Fire Island that include morning breakfast include:

  • Penthouse Bedroom B.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • Dexter Bedroom A.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 10.0
  • Madison Bedroom B.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 10.0

Some of the best Bed And Breakfast in Fire Island are:

  • Mod 8 / private bath & deck.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.52
  • Newly Renovated Studio for 2 in Cherry Grove, FI.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.86
  • One Bedroom Cottage in Cherry Grove.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.84

Some of the popular Bed And Breakfast in Fire Island are:

  • Mod 8 / private bath & deck.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.52
  • Newly Renovated Studio for 2 in Cherry Grove, FI.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.86
  • One Bedroom Cottage in Cherry Grove.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 9.84