Charming Cottages in Fire Island, NY

Coastal Cove Cottage
Hotel
Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA

Coastal Cove Cottage is located in Ocean Bay Park, a 2-minute walk from Ocean Beach. All rooms feature a kitchen, a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, and a private bathroom. At the hotel, each room comes with a patio. Guest rooms will provide guests with a desk and a coffee machine.

Amenities:

Security/Safety • Child Friendly • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Guest Services • Fireplace/Heating

5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

With a big outdoor deck, and an oversized living space inside, you'll have a classic Fire Island experience rain or shine. We've updated the interior keeping some of the authentic features -- exposed cedar, wood beams -- and augmented that with modern furniture and appliances. Our back deck is fully private, with a grill, outdoor shower, and lounge area, and has a great vibe for hanging day or night. With the Ocean Beach restaurant scene just a few minutes away, you can stay in or go out with ease! Feel free to take advantage of our beach cruisers too for exploring -- either just hopping around Ocean Beach or going to the farther away towns of Seaview or Ocean Bay Park. For sleeping -- our 2 downstairs bedrooms have blackout curtains for a good night's sleep. Our upstairs bedroom has a queen and ample storage. Plus, we have a small 'nook' overlooking the large living space with two chairs that fold into sleeping mats -- the perfect hideout for kids.

Amenities:

Wellness Facilities • Other • Air Conditioner • Fireplace/Heating • Security/Safety • Bedding/Linens • Tv • Kitchen • Laundry • Internet • Child Friendly • Sports/Activities

Historic quaint beach cozy 4-bedroom cottage in beautiful Cherry Grove
Cottage
Fire Island, New York, USA

Experience the tranquility of Pride House, an idyllic beach cottage nestled in the heart of Cherry Grove. This retreat perfectly blends comfort with charm, creating a home away from home for all guests.

Inside, you'll find a warm and inviting living room where comfortable seating invites you to unwind. The fully equipped kitchen meets all your culinary needs, while the dining area is perfect for enjoying meals. The spacious bedroom features a luxurious queen-sized bed, and the clean, modern bathroom offers a refreshing sanctuary.

Step outside to discover the enchanting outdoor areas. Relax on the patio, swing gently in the hammock, or enjoy a BBQ with friends. After a day at the beach, rinse off in the refreshing outdoor shower. The lush, well-maintained gardens enveloping the cottage add to the serene and peaceful ambiance.

Pride House is not just any beach cottage; it is one of the original beach homes of Cherry Grove, built in the 1930s. It maintains all its original charm and character, featuring numerous windows that let in abundant sunlight and offer garden views. Listen to the waves crashing on the nearby beach and the harmonious birdsongs echoing throughout the property.

There is also a maintenance man who visits once a week to ensure the garden remains pristine by watering the plants and sweeping the areas.

Pride House is your ideal destination for relaxation and rejuvenation. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway or a quiet escape, this charming beach cottage promises a memorable stay. Book your stay at Pride House today and let the tranquility of Cherry Grove wash over you.

Amenities:

Security/Safety • Bedding/Linens • Tv • Fireplace/Heating • Kitchen • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Wellness Facilities • Internet • Other • Oceanfront • Ocean View • View

Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space
Cottage
Fair Harbor, New York, USA

Charming 5BR Bay Front Beach Cottage located on the bay beach in Fair Harbor.

*** KAYAK rentals AVAILABLE***

For over 10 years, our guests' experiences have been wonderful and their stay created fond family and friend memories.

Our home has 1930's cottage charm - roomy, very clean, neat and well appointed for your comfort & privacy. With several outdoor dining and private lounging areas and decks, there is plenty of room throughout the property for guests and their friends to eat, chill and relax together or privately.

Our cottage is very conveniently located on the Great South Bay and bay beach, a one minute walk to the ferry and small town (which has a convenience store, a food market, pizza and ice cream shops, & the doctor’s office), and a 3 minute walk to the ocean beach. The cottage is far enough away to maintain quiet and privacy.

Summer on Fire Island is truly paradise. The ocean is warm, the weather is perfect, the sunrises and sunsets are spectacular, the fish are jumping, the surf is sensational, clamming, wind surfing, sailing and boating are exceptional activities, the summer residents are cool, and life is beautiful.. As you can see, I love it here and spend a lot of my time in this paradise.

Fair Harbor is one of the friendliest, laid-back Fire Island communities, hosting the best restaurant and social sunset gatherings on the dock every evening.

Features:
- Beautiful, Screened-In Front Porch with World Class Bay and Sunset Views.
Front porch has a dining table that seats 10 and a living area that seats 7 plus
- Washer & Dryer.
- Large & private back deck with large wicker sectional couch, two patio dining tables and seating areas for ten plus guests
-Gas BBQ
- Front deck and beach sand living areas that casually seat ten people
-Outdoor shower
- A/C
- Quality Linens, Towels & Beach Towels
- Original nautical art work.

Other Beach and Water Sport Activities Available:
- motor boating.
- water skiing and wake boarding.
- fishing.
- sailing.
- surfing.
- clamming.
- Kayaking.

Keywords: Fire Island, Dunewood, Lonelyville, Saltaire, Kismet, Ocean Beach, Ocean Bay Park, Summer beach cottage, bay front, beach, bay views, on the bay, sunset views; beach house, Classic beach house architecture, Casual, relaxed, beach lifestyle, on the bay, on the beach, beach front, beachfront

Guest Reviews:

- "Our family and friends stayed here for a weekend, and the location was perfect. Right on the bay and near the stores. Roberto was great to work with and was very accessible. A great place for a weekend at the beach." - "We have been renting in Fair Harbor for years but this rental has been the best..BY FAR! There is NO better view in Fair Harbor. Wake to views of the ferry pulling back not there dock & the calm Great South Bay. The sunset view, from the front porch, is life-changing. The home is about 100 years old but lovingly maintained with all the cozy comforts you need for a beach vacation. Roberto was a fantastic host & communication was seamless. We have found our dream beach house & will DEFINITELY be renting again!"

Designer cottage with amazing view, serene deck & outdoor shower - walk to beach
Cottage
Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA

Huron Hideaway

Our calendar is updated in real-time & our nightly rates are accurately displayed. Simply enter your desired dates and click 'Book Now!'

Located four houses from the sandy beach, this completely renovated cottage offers a classic Fire Island experience with a chance to get away from the noise and hustle of day-to-day life. While here, check out Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop shop for watersports lessons as well as parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals. Spend a hot summer's day at the Sunken Forest, about two miles east, and enjoy some shade and take a ranger-led walk through the trees, and then spend an evening filling up on delicious food at one of the many nearby restaurants. And after a gorgeous day on the sand, walk over to Hideaway for dinner and drinks on the bay.

After a fun day out and about, rinse off any residual sand in the outdoor shower and return to a relaxing and serene hideaway. The designer interior features an open-concept living space illuminated by abundant natural lighting. Enjoy the coolness of the central air-conditioning as you lounge comfortably on the new furniture to watch your favorite streaming service on the TV there. A bonus flex space features gorgeous custom built-in seating and a table perfect for remote work.

The group chef will adore the newly renovated and spacious kitchen, as well as its new appliances. Keep the chef company at the center island, then gather for memorable meals in the stylish dining room. Better yet, take the food to the furnished deck and dine alfresco as you gaze at the nearby greenery. As your day winds a close, take refuge in one of the plush beds. The primary suite is especially enticing, in large part thanks to the brand-new ensuite, which features a roomy walk-in shower.

You won't find many cottages like this on Fire Island and after staying here, you won't want to leave!

Things to Know
Streaming services are available with guests' own account(s).
A green cage wagon is available for use.
No cars are allowed on the island.
All guests shall abide by Vacasa's good neighbor policy. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m.
Vacasa is a registered New York State sales tax vendor. And if Vacasa is the merchant of record will collect sales tax and applicable unit fees on all sales of short-term rental unit occupancy within New York State that it facilitates.

Parking notes: No parking available.

Please note: this home resides in a noise-sensitive area and the owners participate in our Good Neighbor protection program. Our smart home technology will alert our team if excessive decibel or occupancy levels are detected, allowing us to reach out directly with a reminder of maximum occupancy and quiet hours. This technology is privacy compliant, and only monitors the presence of decibels and devices-not any personal conversation or information. Thank you for supporting our efforts to be good neighbors!

Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a nightly damage waiver fee, plus tax if applicable (the “Damage Waiver”). (A discount may be applied for stays of 28 nights or longer, if permitted.) The Damage Waiver covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. The Damage Waiver fee eliminates the need for a traditional security deposit.
More information can be downloaded from the "Rental Agreement" on the checkout page.

Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.

Guest Reviews:

- "This is the perfect getaway for anyone looking for an upscale, updated yet homey quaint cottage. With all the brand new appliances and amenities and crisp linens only steps from the ocean, we could not ask for more. It even had new a/c and heating individual wall units in each bedroom and the main living area. The outdoor shower had amazing water pressure and was a little slice of heaven after a long day at the ocean/beach. It was a perfect stay for our little family get away!"

Beach Cottage on Fire Island
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Steps from the ocean, spacious and recently remodeled home ready for your beach vacation!

Casita Del Mar has it all! Enjoy a wonderful trip to the beach while staying in the very desirable and convenient Ocean Bay Park neighborhood on Fire Island. The home is located a quick 5 minute walk from the beach, the ferry, local restaurants and a charming grocery store.
The space
From the moment you arrive, you will truly love the beachy feel of the cottage.

Kitchen:
This beautiful vacation home has a brand new kitchen, stainless steel appliances & hardwood floors. Lots of pots and pans, knives, microwave, dishware, utensils, french press, toaster oven, dishwasher.

Living Room:
The interior is spacious and full of light with a wonderful open concept flow. There is a Roku TV with streaming capabilities.

Dining Space:
The Dining area offers seating for up to 7.

Outdoor Space:
There is an enormous wraparound outdoor patio. Lots of seating options, a propane grill, and two outdoor showers.

Beach:
There are beach chairs/umbrellas to use.

*There is Spilt Unit ACs and Heating*

The home sleeps 10. Please note the bedroom spaces are on the smaller side.
BR1 has a queen bed
BR2 has a double and a twin
BR3 has two twins
BR4 has a double and a twin

The family dogs (weighing up to 40 pounds each) are welcome with a small nightly fee

During these worrisome and challenging times, we will try every possible way to make you feel safe and comfortable.

Check In: 4pm
Check Out: 10am

Everyone must be over the age of 25 to rent this home. We have a strict NO smoking policy and NO party policy. There will be a $1,000 dollar fine for any smoking/parties on the property.

Please Note: This is a home on an ISLAND so sometimes things will move a little slower. There are no refunds for weather.
Guest access
You will access Ocean Bay Park at The Bayshore Ferry Terminal. Parking is at the terminal. Please check out the fire island ferries schedule for more information.

Guest Reviews:

- "Our stay at this beach house was wonderful! Plenty of room, clean and so convenient to the beaches and restaurants." - "Perfect location/home for a girls getaway weekend!" - "Clean, well taken care of. Great communication" - "This house was the most PERFECT house for my family for our weekend. The house had everything we needed. The perfect amount of rooms, the perfect location, the perfect decor, I can't praise this place enough. Lily is a great host, very responsive and sweet. We stayed Labor Day Weekend and she did not change the prices due to us finding it before anything was updated and that was more than appreciated by us. I hope I get the chance to stay there again! Definitely recommending this house to all my Long Island friends/family. Thank you Lily!"

Classic Beach House & Cottage!
Cottage
Fire Island, New York, USA

Our home is perfect for a quiet vacation with family or friends. It is secluded with foliage, privacy and the rhythm of the waves and the music of the birds. The house has a beautiful front deck to enjoy your morning coffee and newspaper. It also has a large private back deck to linger over a quiet dinner with family and friends. An outdoor umbrella is shared under the canopy of a large Oak tree.

The interior of the home has been renovated to complete detail. The living room includes a very comfortable sofa with rattan club chairs. The indoor dining area provides a table and chairs or if you prefer, use it as a large desk. There are two bedrooms in the house with a Sofa and a Large cottage on the back deck. There is a full bath in the house and a half bath in the cottage. Bedroom #1 has a Queen Size bed with a Flat Screen TV, A/C and ceiling fan. Bedroom #2 has a Bunk Bed with an A/C, Flat Screen & a TV. In addition, there is a Glorious Outdoor Shower on the Back Deck. The kitchen is stainless and white with butcher block and granite counters. The home is also well equipped with a Weber Gas Grill, Bikes and a large wagon (including beach chairs and beach umbrellas.) This vacation story completes a rare and perfect union. Take a glass of wine to the dock, to meet your neighbors and watch the Sunset! Come back again!

Guest Reviews:

- "It’s a well-equipped house perfectly located halfway between the beach and the bay, so it’s close to everything. Beds are comfy and the four of us had everything we needed. Would definitely stay here again!" - "The house had a comfortable cottage feel - close to the beach and the bay/ferry. Fair Harbor is terrific." - "I almost don’t want to write this review because I don’t want anyone else to rent this home. This is the CUTEST beach house we have ever stayed in. Fair Harbor is paradise & this house is perfection. There are bikes, a wagon, BBQ gas grill, all kitchen & household goods & a wonderful, outdoor shower! (Nothing like showering under the stars on a warm, Fire Island evening after a king day at the ocean. The little cottage behind the house was just an added bonus! My teenage daughter loved having her own space. There is a/c in every room for really hot nights but the ocean breezes flow right through the house so we really didn’t need them. It’s a 60 second walk to the ocean & maybe 5 mins to the bay & town. We will DEFINITELY be renting this beach house again!"

Fully Booked for Summer 2023 - Charming Cottage, Perfect Location!
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Leave your car, shoes and the noise of the city behind. Ocean Beach (OB) on Fire Island is a charming small community without cars, where residents walk barefoot to the beach, ride bicycles and use wagons to carry belongings. We have enjoyed our summers here for 50+ years, and we think your family will love it too!

Fire Island is part of the National Seashore, and Ocean Beach (OB) is its largest town (8 blocks). An incorporated village, OB has 3 designated swimming areas with lifeguards at both the ocean and the Great South Bay, 2 playgrounds, a school library, movies, dock concerts, a day camp, tennis , pickleball, basketball & tennis courts, softball field, and plenty of shops and restaurants.

Lovely, 105 y.o. 3BR beach cottage with modern amenities.
• 2 minute walk to beach on same block where lifeguards are on duty
• Large private deck offers both shade and sun, BBQ, lounge chairs & picnic table with umbrella
• Spacious living room with AC, fireplace, dining table, and comfortable sitting areas.
• Modern kitchen with gas stove/oven, dishwasher, micro, coffee makers
• 3 Renovated bedrooms (2 with AC)
• Renovated full indoor bathroom and shower
• Verizon Fios Wireless 500/500
• Front and back screened-in porches with both sitting and dining areas
• Outdoor half bathroom next to outdoor shower
• Enclosed outdoor shower & changing area
• Bicycles (4 adult size), hammock, blueberry bushes
• Beach towels, beach chairs, beach umbrellas and sand toys
• A/C in Living Room and 2 bedrooms (3 total)
• Catholic & Protestant churches and Synagogue nearby

Guest Reviews:

- "We felt like we were in a home that we would actually wont to own! it was well stocked, cutely decorated, and very comfortable. Having two screened in porches gave us different places to spend time as a family in the mornings and evenings. It was in a perfect location close to town, but also far enough away that it was quite at night. The owner was easily accessible, easy to work with, and cared about how our trip went. She touched base during and at the end of our vacation. We would definitly consider renting this home again."

Idyllic Cozy Cottage in Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available!
Cottage
Patchogue, New York, USA

Escape to your perfect getaway and experience the ultimate beach retreat on Spindrift Walk in Davis Park, Fire Island! This enchanting single-story cottage, previously rented for the entire season, is now available for weekly rentals. Don’t miss your chance to enjoy this serene retreat and secure your spot in this coveted paradise today.

Key Features:
• Spacious Outdoor Deck: Bask in the sun or enjoy evening gatherings on the large wraparound deck extending from the west to the south side.

• Comfortable Accommodations: Sleeps 6+ with 2 full beds, a bedroom with 2 single beds, and 2 additional couches for extra sleeping space.

• Prime Beach Access: A short stroll to the pristine Atlantic Ocean beaches and the calm waters of the Great South Bay, perfect for swimming, sunbathing, and leisurely walks.

Modern Amenities:

• Fully-Equipped Kitchen: Granite countertops, dishwasher, microwave, toaster, coffee makers, oven, and complete tableware—just bring your favorite foods.

• Conveniences Galore: Washer/dryer, window AC units, WiFi, and all necessary linens provided for your stay.

• Entertainment Ready: TV with DVD player and ceiling fans in the living room ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

• Outdoor Delight: Gas grill (propane provided), outdoor picnic table with shade umbrella, and both indoor and outdoor showers for a refreshing experience.
Community Highlights:

• Dining & Essentials: Delight in delicious cuisine at The Casino, featuring beach and snack bars. The Harbor Store has all your essentials and fresh fish on order.

• Serene Surroundings: Embrace the peaceful ambiance of Fire Island, with its friendly neighbors, scenic boardwalks, and untouched natural beauty.

• Nature & Tranquility: Immerse yourself in the natural beauty of Fire Island with a short walk to Watch Hill National Seashore.

Booking Details:

• Weekly Rental Period: Monday 4 PM to Monday 10 AM

Don't miss your chance to unwind and rejuvenate in this tranquil oasis. Book your stay now and indulge in the serene beauty of Davis Park, Fire Island. Perfect for beach lovers, nature enthusiasts, and anyone seeking a peaceful retreat. Your dream vacation awaits!

Amenities:

Kitchen • Tv • Pet Friendly • Wellness Facilities • Air Conditioner • Fireplace/Heating • Bedding/Linens • Internet • Balcony/Terrace • Entertainment • Security/Safety • Laundry

Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl
Cottage
Fire Island Pines, New York, USA

Private Pines Sanctuary that’s close enough to never miss out on the action in far enough to escape room the Harbor parties or beach get together’s. Decide for yourself to stay nestled in your own private Yard & Pool, Or gather with the masses in the harbor and beaches.

Guest Reviews:

- "Overall good experience. There was some construction in progress that was not ideal, but nice to see investment harpooning as well. Would be good to have a guest instruction sheet. But overall a nice place in a great location." - "Overall, I was pleased with the attentiveness of the host and the location of the property. Would come back!"

Fair Harbor Fire island
Cottage
Bay Shore, New York, USA

Our cozy cottage is waiting for you! June only
Newly Renovated new kitchen 3 bedrooms 2 baths outdoor shower. Large deck 700 feet to the ocean. Beach chairs, 5 bikes, bbq,
Dog friendly after approval 3 night min

Amenities:

Fireplace/Heating • Security/Safety • Pet Friendly • Wellness Facilities • Internet • Laundry • Bedding/Linens • Balcony/Terrace • Air Conditioner • Child Friendly • Kitchen

Classic Fire Island! Adorable Seaview Cottage - 2nd house from the beach.
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Be inspired: Maurice Sendak wrote 'Where The Wild Things Are' while summering in this house!

Our little house built in 1925 is perfect for a quiet vacation... or a writer's retreat. Our home, secluded by dense foliage, gives privacy and silence that is only punctuated by the music of the changing tides and the birds' call. We are the second house from the beach -- roll out of the bed and into the ocean!
Seaview is a quiet family community with lifeguards, kiddie pool and bay beach access, free swimming lessons, activities for children, baseball field, playground, tennis courts, and the best market on the island- Seaview Market! 7 minute walk to the ferry. Very close to Ocean Beach with shops and restaurants.
There are 4 bedrooms, all with A/C and overhead fans - 1 queen size bed, 1 full size bed, 2 rooms with 2 single beds. A portable A/C unit is downstairs as well as fans. For those colder months, there is a wood-burning fireplace. There are 1 1/2 baths plus a glorious outside shower.
The kitchen is fully equipped. There is a grill for outside dining on the deck. This is not a rental home, but our family home that we rent out only for a brief period every summer.
Lifeguards on the ocean and bay beach. Baby pool (and free swimming lessons) and playground - basket ball court access. Baseball field.
Minutes from Seaview Market/Ferry and Ocean Beach.

*NB: Please contact us for any interest! We don't accept automatic bookings due to community regulations: we prefer to communicate with you first to make sure our house is a good fit for you. Rentals are usually from Monday to Sunday. Thanks for your patience.

Guest Reviews:

- "Loved the house - tons of charm, huge deck, and just steps away from the ocean. large library of books and lots of cozy nooks for reading. recommended!" - "This Seaview house has lots of character and just steps from the beach. The house, which dates from the '20s, is filled with books and has a wonderful welcoming atmosphere. Unlike some older houses, it is very bright. The location is fantastic, being just one house from the beach. Also, the house has an unusual amount of open space around it. The owner provided lots of bikes, beach towels, beach chairs, umbrellas, etc. and the kitchen facilities were great. This is clearly a much loved home rather than a dedicated rental property. This part of Seaview is very quiet, but is close to the bustle and facilities of Ocean Beach. We wouldn't hesitate to rent this house again. "

Original 2-bedroom cottage in lovely Fair Harbor with WiFi
Cottage
Fair Harbor, New York, USA

If you enjoy a truly Fire Island experience, try our original, shotgun-style fisherman’s cottage dating from the ‘20s. Sleeps four in two bedrooms (twin beds in loft, full-size bed in guesthouse), with single bed in dining room for a visiting guest. Super sunny side porch, screened-in back yard, indoor and outdoor shower, TV, Verizon FIOS, Weber grill, washer/dryer, microwave, bikes, wagon, linens and towels.

Amenities:

Kitchen • Other • Pet Friendly • Bedding/Linens • Child Friendly • Laundry

Ocean Beach,FI Cottage sleeps 2
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Coupes Getaway!! Ocean Beach Cottage ideal for a couple. Similar to a studio apartment with everything you need to enjoy a stay in Ocean Beach. Queen size bed, bathroom, outdoor shower & small kitchenette. The cottage is a separate structure on the property with the main house so it has shared deck space (patio furniture, table, BBQ, etc.).

Close to town and all other amenities.

Amenities:

Child Friendly • Air Conditioner • Bedding/Linens

Enchanting 3 BR Home on a Beach Block - Now Booking for 2024 \/ Ocean Beach, NY
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

In compliance with Ocean Beach rental laws, a 6-night minimum stay is required. Weeklies run from Mondays at Noon to Sundays at 5:00 pm

This home has earned many, many Five-Star Reviews on VRBO!

PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR OUR 2024 RATES

If you're looking for a very special summer rental, our charming and cozy 135+ year-old beach house may be just what you’re hoping to find. Located on a beach block in Ocean Beach, it suffered absolutely no damage whatsoever from Hurricane Sandy. A/C in two of the three bedrooms plus the dining room and kitchen. Open stud construction with cathedral ceilings, exposed rafters, and a huge wood-burning fireplace - said to be the largest on the island. Gleaming original wood floors with sand-catching sea grass carpeting in the living and dining rooms. Sleeps 7 but 5 more comfortably. Lovingly furnished, in immaculate condition, and generously stocked with every amenity to make your stay comfortable and memorable. For further information, call Linda at 415.867.4727. I'm on West Coast time.

NOTE:
• This is not a grouper/share-rental; no sublets permitted
• Well-mannered pets welcome
• Smoking on porch and deck only

2024 WEEKLY RATES:
Weeklies run from Mondays at 12 Noon to Sundays at 5:00 pm.
• June, $2800 week* (after 6/20/22)
• July, $4000 week*
• August, $4000 week*
• September, $2800 week*
• October, $1800 week* (until approx 10/16/24)

* We also require a 20% security deposit, $160 for professional cleaning, $125 for the rental permit, a flat fee of $60/wk for utilities (gas, propane for BBQ, electric, FIOS wireless internet, and DirectTV), and the 5.5% Suffolk County Hotel tax.

DETAILS:
Front Porch:
Screened porch is shaded by tall pines and blueberry bushes. Round table seats 4. Two comfy armchairs for relaxing.

Living Room:
Lovingly furnished with nautical artifacts, framed vintage maritime prints, original oil paintings. Plenty of seating. Antique sideboard and writing desk are stocked with table linens, sewing baskets, stationery supplies, and more.

Dining Room:
Has A/C. Couch converts into two twin beds; 18 ft. window seat, antique oak table (extends to seat 10 comfortably), large TV/DVD/DirectTV; FIOS WiFi. Beautifully decorated with maritime art and bric a brac. Closes off from living room with two sets of curtains - one sheer, one opaque.

Master Bedroom:
Has A/C, antique iron double bed, two dressers (one mirrored). Note: Ample bed and bath linens provided throughout, including charming vintage coverlets, throws, and quilts.

Second Bedroom:
Has A/C, two pine bunk beds with under-bed storage drawers. Decor features vintage bird prints. Perfect for kids. (Note: By saying "two ...bunk beds," we mean ONE 2-level structure equipped with TWO full-sized twin mattress.)

Third Bedroom:
Has antique iron twin day bed, mirrored dresser, whimsical mermaid-motif decor, shared A/C. Although small, it has quick access to the indoor shower, kitchen, and deck - ideal for a Mother's Helper.

Kitchen:
Has A/C. Fully-stocked track lit kitchen with gas stove, microwave, large fridg, double sink, butcher block counter, washer/dryer. Ample dishes, glasses, flatware, pots & pans, bakeware, utensils, kitchen linens, toaster, blender, food chopper, coffee grinder, espresso machine, coffee maker, Brita water pitcher, popsicle maker, and more. We even leave our spices and staples for tenants plus paper goods, cleaning/laundry supplies, and other basic household necessities.

Bathroom:
One divided bathroom. WC closes off from indoor shower.

Decks:
Back deck has outdoor shower, gas BBQ, teak picnic table, w/ large market umbrella, 4 metal dining chairs, lounge chairs, and clothes line. Side deck has storage for wagons, 4 adult coaster bikes, ample beach chairs, and umbrellas.

Other Amenities:
In addition to those noted above, the cottage has many other amenities such as ceiling fans throughout, a vacuum cleaner, space heaters, portable fans, an ironing board and iron, bedside cube clocks, books, games, puzzles, playing cards, CDs, a CD player, rain slickers, flashlights, and more. We also have a big milk crate wagon for getting your belongings from the ferry to the house.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a wonderful stay at the Sandpauper! The house was cozy and comfortable, and had everything we needed! A stocked kitchen. Plenty of linens, towels and blankets. Refreshing outdoor shower. We ate most of our meals on the back deck and spend lots of mornings relaxing with our coffee on the front screened in porch. Great location, a short walk to town and even shorter walk to the beach. Well functioning a/c units. Linda was so attentive to our needs. There was an issue with a troublesome renter of a nearby house, she took our concerns seriously and got on it right away!! We were so impressed with her rapid response and active support. We didn't want to leave!"

Newly Renovated Beauty! 2 bed plus Loft-Cottage Steps From Beach in Ocean Beach
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Brand New- just renovated, be the first to stay! Located in a prime area of Ocean Beach just 7 houses from the beach, this newly renovated 2.5 bedroom cottage is perfect place to stay for a trip to Ocean Beach. The house has beautiful cathedral ceilings as well as a spiral staircase leading to a cozy loft which is used as an additional sleeping area. The extra-large back deck is a beautiful, private new space and great for family barbecues or entertaining. This house is perfect for a family or a friends getaway. Everything is just a walk away; 2 minutes to the beach and 5 minutes into town where you will find restaurants and shopping. The town is kid-friendly with a playground and plenty of activities for kids. Everything is brand new in the house—2024 is the first rental season.
Bedroom 1: Queen bed with half bathroom
Bedroom 2: Queen bed
Loft: 1 Full bed

-Full amenity kitchen
-Beach chairs
-3 Bicycles
-Outdoor grill (brand new)
-Beach and bath towels
-TV/Wifi access
-Large outdoor patio with table, lounge chairs, umbrella

Weekly rentals are 6 days Friday-Thursday, although we will consider 7 day rentals from Friday-Friday as well as multiple week rentals. Strict cleaning standards will be implemented so you will arrive to an impeccably clean home.

***If booking before April 15, 2024 cancellations will be accepted for a full refund within 14 days of booking. After 14 days no refund will be issued. No refunds will be issued for accepted bookings after April 15, 2024 for the summer season. Date changes accepted up to 30 days before your stay pending availability.

Ocean Beach is a town in the heart of Fire Island, NY located just 50 miles from NYC. Just a quick train ride from Manhattan or park your car at the ferry. Pack a bag and go!

Amenities:

Entertainment • Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Other • Child Friendly • Laundry • Air Conditioner • Tv • Kitchen • Internet • Fireplace/Heating • Bedding/Linens • Security/Safety

Fire Island Classic
Cottage
Ocean Beach, New York, USA

Cute 4 bedroom, 1.5 bath home located in Ocean Beach just steps to town and a five minute walk to the beach. The main house has 3 bedrooms and a full bath and the guest house has one bedroom a kitchenette and half bath.

Amenities:

Laundry • Other • Child Friendly • Pet Friendly • Security/Safety

Ocean Bay Park Family Vacation fun
Cottage
Ocean Bay Park

3 bedroom 1 1/2 bath located on the boarder of Ocean Bay Park and Seaview. A guiet area of the island. Fully equipt with a large deck, BBQ, lounge chairs, picnic table, great for entertaining! High ceiling,s clean spacious house 100 yards from the ocean. Discover this barrier island free from cars and pollution! :) Weekly rentals only July and August.

The space
We rent weekly only from July and August. The deposit will be returned upon the house being found in good order. See our Calender for availability. or you can call Tim Bascom, 9am-9pm at (1-212-741-9666).
We are situated on the boarder of Ocean Bay Park and Seaview 1 block from the Seaview Ball field on the corner of Superior and Thompson. It is approximately 100 yards to the beach.
The beach house has a private deck on the west side of the house great for afternoon sun and relaxation. The house comes fully equipped with everything you need for a great week. There is an entrance conveniently located off the deck to the kitchen so eating outdoors or indoors has easy access. Trees and a diamond fence surround the deck and property. We have a 3 bedroom, 1½ baths and outdoor shower. The living room has a wood-burning stove although during the summer months it is not used. Indoors we have a good-sized dining area to entertain and a large living room with very high ceilings. There is a TV, VHS, stereo and plenty of tapes as well as games, cards and books…
The 3 bedrooms consist of a large master with a king sized bed, AC and a ceiling fan. The second bedroom has 2 twin beds AC and a Washer /Dryer. The third bedroom has AC and a king.
There is another entrance from the street to the living room and small deck that wraps around to the large deck. There is a wagon and some FI bikes. Please always keep them locked at all times.
We have a care takers guesthouse next door, which is separated by a fence on the eastern side of the property with a separate entrance to the street as well as separate deck. The only adjoining wall is bedroom against bedroom and is very well insulated. The spaces are separate and you always have privacy. The good news here is that if you have any questions about Fire Island, restaurants , shopping, hiking, freight, water taxis… we are there to help out! We have never had any complaints.
Since we are in a quiet area of the island with an uncrowded beach, we do our best to respect all our neighbors and ask our tenants to do the same. This is a magical place!
We are a block away from the ball field and the children’s baseball games begin at 8:30 Am on Sat. and Sun. Teens game is at 5Pm. Fri and Sat. We are also one block to a wonderful playground as well as the beach or the bay.
We ask that all outdoor dinners end at 10 PM so the police don’t come. They can be called by a neighbor although we have not had that happen yet. We cherish our neighbors and respect their privacy. However, we have children as well and understand it is not a perfect world. Please do not get us wrong, we believe in live and let live. We just want all parties involved to be on the same page. This is not a grouper house or a frat party house, no beer pong, no parties !We want you to enjoy your time on Fire Island.
If you have any questions you can reach me at (1-212-741-9666), I am happy to discuss the house with you or answer any questions you may have.
We look forward to another great summer.
If you are interested please tell us about yourselves as well please send us your name and address.
Best wishes,
Timothy Bascom and Rachelle King

Guest access
Check in is after 5 and check out is at 10am unless otherwise stated.

Other things to note
All out door dinner parties must end at 10pm. No smoking in the house. No parties!

Beach Home on Fire Island/Dog Friendly
Cottage
Fire Island

Steps from the ocean in Ocean Bay Park, spacious and recently remodeled home ready for your beach vacation!

Casita Del Mar has it all! Enjoy a wonderful trip to the beach while staying in the very desirable and convenient Ocean Bay Park neighborhood on Fire Island. The home is located a quick 5 minute walk from the beach, the ferry, local restaurants and a charming grocery store.

The space
From the moment you arrive, you will truly love the beachy feel of the cottage.

Kitchen:
This beautiful vacation home has a brand new kitchen, stainless steel appliances & hardwood floors. Lots of pots and pans, knives, microwave, dishware, utensils, french press, toaster oven, dishwasher.

Living Room:
The interior is spacious and full of light with a wonderful open concept flow. There is a Roku TV with streaming capabilities.

Dining Space:
The Dining area offers seating for up to 7.

Outdoor Space:
There is an enormous wraparound outdoor patio. Lots of seating options, a propane grill, and two outdoor showers.

Beach:
There are beach chairs/umbrellas to use.

*There is Spilt Unit ACs and Heating*

The home sleeps 10. Please note the bedroom spaces are on the smaller side.
BR1 has a queen bed
BR2 has a double and a twin
BR3 has two twins
BR4 has a double and a twin

The family dogs (weighing up to 40 pounds each) are welcome with a nightly fee

During these worrisome and challenging times, we will try every possible way to make you feel safe and comfortable.

Check In: 4pm
Check Out: 10am


We have a strict NO smoking policy and NO party policy. There will be a $1,000 dollar fine for any smoking/parties on the property.

Please Note: This is a home on an ISLAND so sometimes things will move a little slower. There are no refunds for weather.

We have outdoor surveillance cameras for safety.

Guest access
You will access Ocean Bay Park at The Bayshore Ferry Terminal. Parking is at the terminal. Please check out the fire island ferries schedule for more information.

Other things to note
There will be a 10% Management Fee Tax charged through AIRBNB'S resolution center for each booking.

Amenities:

Washer • Dryer • Bed linens • TV • Bathtub • Ceiling fan • Outdoor shower • Hot water • Hair dryer • Air conditioning

Fair Harbor, Fire Island, 3 Bdrm, Prime Spot
Cottage
Fire Island

Three bedroom A-frame with private front and back decks in perfect location. Three bedrooms (2 queen, 1 single with pop up trundle). Charming wooden structure, lofted ceilings, terracotta floors. Light, sunny, leafy, breezy

Guest access
internet, tv, netflix

Amenities:

Shower gel • Dryer • Hair dryer • Cleaning products • Shampoo • Outdoor shower • Hot water • Washer • Hangers • Essentials

Ocean Beach Bayview Cottage
Cottage
Ocean Beach

This peaceful haven has everything you need to feel at home. Beach towels, beach chairs, beach umbrellas, and a wagon are provided. This cozy cottage is only a 2-minute walk to the bay swimming area, playground and the best dining and shopping spots in town. Life here is easy, convenient, and fun. Here the stresses of everyday life melt away with the tide and you can create new vacation memories.

Amenities:

Outdoor shower • Dryer • Hair dryer • Essentials • Hot water • Shampoo • Washer • Hangers • Bay view • Garden view

Lovely Home Ocean Bay Park
Cottage
Fire Island

Well maintained 3 bedroom 2 full bathroom home.
Eat in kitchen. Living room with flat screen TV. Third bedroom is a separate cottage with attached full bathroom. Kitchen opens onto the large backyard deck. Large and private backyard with patio sets, gas BBQ, and large outdoor shower. We provide pillows, sheets and light blankets.

Midweek :Monday to Friday
Weekends: Friday -Monday
Full week: Monday-Monday or Friday to Friday

The space
The blue bedroom faces the street it has a queen bed and a twin trundle.
The pink bedroom faces the back it has two twin beds and a twin trundle.
The third bedroom has two twin over full bunk beds.

Guest access
Guests have the sole use of the front porch and backyard which has two large decks and outdoor shower and the house which has a full bath and two bedrooms, living room and eat in kitchen and the cottage with another bedroom and full bath.

Other things to note
To access streaming services, you will need to use your own personal accounts and passwords.

☀️NEW LISTING! 2BR Oceanview Hideaway☀️
Cottage
Fire Island

New Listing in the Exclusive Corneille Estates located in Ocean Beach, Fire Island

Soak in the sun and ocean views in this Fire Island 2 bedroom peaceful retreat! Great for families, groups of friends or couples with kids.

★ Hurry and reserve your beach getaway before your dates are booked!
★ Linens and towels provided!
★Steps away from the beach, this beautiful beach cottage is spacious, clean and private!

The space
Sit back, relax, and enjoy all that Fire Island has to offer at this peaceful & private beachside cottage:

*Fall asleep listening to the ocean waves in all of the bedrooms

*Make a delicious meal to share in the fully equipped kitchen

* Enjoy the sun, meals, morning coffee and afternoon cocktails on the large private deck.

*Linens and bath towels provided

*Please plan to bring your own beach towels, toiletries and plenty of sunscreen!

*Washer/dryer

*Wi-Fi and Cable TV

* A/C

*Outdoor shower

*BBQ

*Restaurants, shops, and local attractions walking distance


There is tons to do for of all ages around the Fire Island area. Surfing, kayaking, paddle boarding, and biking are all favorites among the locals. Ocean Beach features some great restaurants, bars and local shops, which are all within walking distance. Take a ride on the water taxis to the famous Fire Island light house, or Sunken Forest. Explore and relax at the Atlantic Ocean or Great South Bay, both minutes walk from the house!

Amenities:

Cleaning products • Extra pillows and blankets • Bed linens • Outdoor shower • Dryer • Hot water • Essentials • TV • Hangers • Free washer – In unit

Classic Fire Island Pines Cottage
Cottage
Fire Island

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Steps to the ocean and perched high on a secondary dune. Classic mid century cottage with multilevel terraces and a peak of the ocean. Quiet, peaceful, and private.
Please message directly for long stay inquiries ( dates may be blocked on the calendar).

The space
The tranquil mid century cottage is a 30 second walk to the ocean. Wrap around multi level decking with comfortable design outdoor furniture makes dinner or relaxing outdoors a pleasure.

Doors and windows all have screens.
Smart TV for sign in to Netflix, Amazon, Hulu etc.
Nespresso Vertuo Machine
Brita water filter in fridge
Berkey water filter on counter
Outdoor grill
Beach chairs and Tent in storage

Guest access
Access to entire home.
Washer, dryer and 1/2 bath on lower level.

Other things to note
Please no shoes indoors as the floors are white.

There is a hose outdoors to remove sand prior to home entry.

Not suitable for children under 4 due to decking elevation.

**This is strictly a NON -SMOKING home. No incense, sage, candles etc. DO NOT leave grill unattended-major fire hazard. Smoke detectors false alarms are costly. **

No “Flushable wipes”, no sanitary products, tampons, or paper towels. It will clog and break are delicate septic sewage system.

Stays longer than 2 weeks will require an interim cleaning at an additional cost of $ 150

No parties.

Perfect for 2 couples.

This is our Family home. Please be gentle and kind to it.

Designer 3BR in Bay Shore - walk to beach
Cottage
Fire Island

The space
Huron Hideaway

Located four houses from the sandy beach, this completely renovated cottage offers a classic Fire Island experience with a chance to get away from the noise and hustle of day-to-day life. While here, check out Fire Island SUP Co. - a one-stop shop for watersports lessons as well as parasailing, paddleboard, and tubing rentals. Spend a hot summer's day at the Sunken Forest, about two miles east, and enjoy some shade and take a ranger-led walk through the trees, and then spend an evening filling up on delicious food at one of the many nearby restaurants. And after a gorgeous day on the sand, walk over to Hideaway for dinner and drinks on the bay.

After a fun day out and about, rinse off any residual sand in the outdoor shower and return to a relaxing and serene hideaway. The designer interior features an open-concept living space illuminated by abundant natural lighting. Enjoy the coolness of the central air-conditioning as you lounge comfortably on the new furniture to watch your favorite streaming service on the TV there. A bonus flex space features gorgeous custom built-in seating and a table perfect for remote work.

The group chef will adore the newly renovated and spacious kitchen, as well as its new appliances. Keep the chef company at the center island, then gather for memorable meals in the stylish dining room. Better yet, take the food to the furnished deck and dine alfresco as you gaze at the nearby greenery. As your day winds a close, take refuge in one of the plush beds. The primary suite is especially enticing, in large part thanks to the brand-new ensuite, which features a roomy walk-in shower.

You won't find many cottages like this on Fire Island and after staying here, you won't want to leave!

Things to Know
Streaming services are available with guests' own account(s).
A green cage wagon is available for use.
No cars are allowed on the island.
All guests shall abide by Vacasa's good neighbor policy. Quiet hours are from 10:00 p.m. to 8:00 a.m.
Vacasa is a registered New York State sales tax vendor. And if Vacasa is the merchant of record will collect sales tax and applicable unit fees on all sales of short-term rental unit occupancy within New York State that it facilitates.
No dog(s) are welcome in this home. No other animals are allowed without specific Vacasa approval.

Parking notes: No parking available.





Please note: this home resides in a noise-sensitive area and the owners participate in our Good Neighbor protection program. Our smart home technology will alert our team if excessive decibel or occupancy levels are detected, allowing us to reach out directly with a reminder of maximun occupancy and quiet hours. This technology is privacy compliant, and only monitors the presence of decibels and devices -not any personal conversation or information. Thank you for supporting our efforts to be good neighbors!


Damage waiver: The total cost of your reservation for this Property includes a damage waiver fee which covers you for up to $3,000 of accidental damage to the Property or its contents (such as furniture, fixtures, and appliances) as long as you report the incident to the host prior to checking out. More information can be found from the "Additional rules" on the checkout page.

Due to local laws or HOA requirements, guests must be at least 30 years of age to book. Guests under 30 must be accompanied by a parent or legal guardian for the duration of the reservation.

Amenities:

Shampoo • TV with Netflix • Air conditioning • Outdoor shower • Hot water • Essentials • Hair dryer • Bed linens • Dryer – In unit • Washer – In unit

Fire Island Pines Designer Home
Cottage
Fire Island

Escape to the timeless charm of Fire Island Pines at this historic 1954 cottage, renovated by an acclaimed AD100 designer, offering vintage allure and modern comfort. Short walk from the harbor and the beach.
3 cozy bedrooms, 2 modern baths, a newly equipped kitchen with luxury appliances, all new designer furniture and new beds.
Fireplace, hot tub, outdoor shower & grill. It's the perfect retreat for relaxation and fun. FIOS Internet. Washer/Dryer. AC in every room.
Available for select weeks.

The space
Each room has a queen size bed. Linen and towels provided.

Rarely available: 3BR in OBP, 6 houses from beach
Cottage
Fire Island

Special opportunity to rent a home with a relaxing garden, grill, and tons of outdoor space and natural light. Great for remote work. Renovated 1970s bungalow with renovated kitchen and bathrooms and open living room. Listen to the birds while you have coffee on the lower deck; dine al fresco under the lights; take a nap in the hammock. This is not a party house, looking for respectful renters that will enjoy our home away from home. On Seaview side of OBP. Easy walk from ferry and Schooners.

Other things to note
Please note that the 5.5% community fee is actually Suffolk County Hotel/Motel Occupancy Tax.

Amenities:

Free dryer – In unit • Cleaning products • Hot water • Free washer – In unit • Bed linens • Outdoor shower • Hangers • Iron • Essentials • Extra pillows and blankets

Family Beach House – 1 block from beach!
Cottage
Fire Island

Only 1 block from the beach, this cozy 3-bedroom home is located on a quiet, family street in Ocean Bay Park.

The house has a fireplace in the living/dining room, bikes, WiFi and chairs/umbrellas for the beach.

Note: I prefer to rent to families and require that all tenants are respectful of the quiet of the neighborhood.

- NO PETS
- NO PARTIES

The space
My cozy, 2-story beach cottage has 2 bedrooms upstairs and a master bedroom with half bath downstairs. The layout is perfect for a family of 6 – the upstairs bedrooms each have 2 single beds, and the downstairs bedroom has a queen-sized bed.

The large deck has an outdoor shower with a view of the backyard, lounge chairs, a sun umbrella, a Weber grill, 2 eating areas and a cabinet with beach umbrellas, chairs and toys.

The kitchen includes a dishwasher, washer/dryer, microwave, toaster oven, coffeemaker and is well-equipped with pots, pans and cooking utensils.

Guest access
Guests have full access to the property, with the exception of two closets that are reserved for the owner’s belongings.

Other things to note
- I do not rent to groups, only families
- This is a QUIET, FAMILY neighborhood, and excessively loud and/or destructive behavior will not be tolerated
- If you are looking for a party house, please select a different listing

Amenities:

Bed linens • Free washer – In unit • Room-darkening shades • Cleaning products • Outdoor shower • Hangers • Extra pillows and blankets • Essentials • Free dryer – In unit • Hot water

Sea Crest Cottage in Saltaire, Fire Island
Cottage
Saltaire

Cozy cottage by the sea in the quiet, family oriented Fire Island Village of Saltaire. Only steps from the beach, this updated and cozy cabin provides open main living spaces along with a large deck.
Walk to the beach to enjoy a day in the sun, or walk or ride bikes into the towns of Fair Harbor, Saltaire, or Kismet to grab a meal at the local restaurants or groceries at the markets. Hop on a water taxi and head to the lively communities of Ocean Beach, Cherry Grove, and the Fire Island Pines!

The space
Single family three bedroom house. Two bathrooms and additional outside shower.
This house is for single family use as defined in the Village Code or no more than two unrelated couples.

Guest access
The Village of Saltaire does not allow cars. You will arrive by ferry and walk or ride bikes to get around.

Other things to note
The cottage is located on a quiet block. This is not a party house but the perfect spot for regrouping with family and friends.

Amenities:

Hot water • Shampoo • Conditioner • Body soap • Free dryer – In unit • Essentials • Washer • Hair dryer • Cleaning products • Outdoor shower

Fire Island Pines Waterfront Oasis - Pool & HotTub
Cottage
Fire Island

🌈❤️‍🔥🏖🌲⛴☀️
FIP WATERFRONT EAST END OASIS
🧜🏼‍♂️👬🪩💃👑⛱

🏡2 Bed, 2.5 Bath
💦Pool
🛁HotTub
🧘‍♂️Outdoor gay-zebo
🚿Best showers in Pines
🌅 Bay views from beds
🌊 Ocean views from rooftop
📺 72” TV
👨‍💻FIOS high speed internet
👑 Fabulous drag closet 💅🏼
⛱ Beach chairs, towels, umbrellas provided

🤳🏼Video tour available 😘

The space
Backing up directly onto the Fire Island National Seashore, your East End waterfront oasis boasts breathtaking views from both bedrooms, office, and even the showers (best shower views in the Pines!). Each bedroom has its own private bathroom, plus an additional half bath for convenience.

Guest access
Entire home oasis, including indoor and outdoor living rooms, pool, hot tub, back deck, and roof deck with built in seating and outdoor dining table with views of Bay and ocean

Amenities:

Conditioner • Shower gel • Shampoo • Washer • Essentials • Hair dryer • Hangers • Cleaning products • Hot water • Dryer

Fire Island Cottages on the Map

Compare the Best Cottages in Fire Island – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Property Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
Coastal Cove Cottage Ocean Bay Park, NY, USA 571 1 Click here
5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway Ocean Beach, New York, USA 909 2.0 10.0 1 Click here
Historic quaint beach cozy 4-bedroom cottage in beautiful Cherry Grove Fire Island, New York, USA 619 2.0 1 Click here
Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space Fair Harbor, New York, USA 859 9.8 39 Click here
Designer cottage with amazing view, serene deck & outdoor shower - walk to beach Ocean Bay Park, New York, USA 1227 9.6 24 Click here
Beach Cottage on Fire Island Ocean Beach, New York, USA 1191 10.0 22 Click here
Classic Beach House & Cottage! Fire Island, New York, USA 850 4.9 6 Click here
Fully Booked for Summer 2023 - Charming Cottage, Perfect Location! Ocean Beach, New York, USA 850 5.0 4 Click here
Idyllic Cozy Cottage in Davis Park, Fire Island - Weekly Rentals Now Available! Patchogue, New York, USA 591 9.0 2 Click here
Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl Fire Island Pines, New York, USA 772 8.0 2 Click here
Fair Harbor Fire island Bay Shore, New York, USA 840 7.0 2 Click here
Classic Fire Island! Adorable Seaview Cottage - 2nd house from the beach. Ocean Beach, New York, USA 1162 10.0 2 Click here
Original 2-bedroom cottage in lovely Fair Harbor with WiFi Fair Harbor, New York, USA 420 1 Click here
Ocean Beach,FI Cottage sleeps 2 Ocean Beach, New York, USA 450 1 Click here
Enchanting 3 BR Home on a Beach Block - Now Booking for 2024 \/ Ocean Beach, NY Ocean Beach, New York, USA 463 1 Click here
Newly Renovated Beauty! 2 bed plus Loft-Cottage Steps From Beach in Ocean Beach Ocean Beach, New York, USA 703 1 Click here
Fire Island Classic Ocean Beach, New York, USA 1028 1 Click here
Ocean Bay Park Family Vacation fun Ocean Bay Park 428 9.0 1 Click here
Beach Home on Fire Island/Dog Friendly Fire Island 501 9.86 1 Click here
Fair Harbor, Fire Island, 3 Bdrm, Prime Spot Fire Island 555 9.8 1 Click here
Ocean Beach Bayview Cottage Ocean Beach 600 1 Click here
Lovely Home Ocean Bay Park Fire Island 625 10.0 1 Click here
☀️NEW LISTING! 2BR Oceanview Hideaway☀️ Fire Island 649 9.7 1 Click here
Classic Fire Island Pines Cottage Fire Island 725 9.84 1 Click here
Designer 3BR in Bay Shore - walk to beach Fire Island 731 9.06 1 Click here
Fire Island Pines Designer Home Fire Island 799 1 Click here
Rarely available: 3BR in OBP, 6 houses from beach Fire Island 800 10.0 1 Click here
Family Beach House – 1 block from beach! Fire Island 900 9.42 1 Click here
Sea Crest Cottage in Saltaire, Fire Island Saltaire 1000 10.0 1 Click here
Fire Island Pines Waterfront Oasis - Pool & HotTub Fire Island 1250 10.0 1 Click here

Note: The prices for each Cottages in Fire Island do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Cottages in Fire Island that include a pool or hot tub include:

  • Private 3BR 3BA Fire Island Cottage w/pool 4 min to harborl.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 8.0
  • Classic Fire Island! Adorable Seaview Cottage - 2nd house from the beach. .- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0

Family-friendly cottages in Fire Island include:

  • Coastal Cove Cottage.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • 5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space.- Review Count: 39, Rating: 9.8

Pet-friendly cottages in Fire Island include:

  • 5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space.- Review Count: 39, Rating: 9.8
  • Beach Cottage on Fire Island.- Review Count: 22, Rating: 10.0

Some of the best Cottages in Fire Island are:

  • 5 houses from the beach, and 5 minutes from town - Ocean Beach 3-BR hideaway.- Review Count: 1, Rating: 10.0
  • Historic quaint beach cozy 4-bedroom cottage in beautiful Cherry Grove.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space.- Review Count: 39, Rating: 9.8

Some of the popular Cottages in Fire Island are:

  • Chill Beachfront Cottage Amazing Bay & Sunset Views! Large Private Outdoor space.- Review Count: 39, Rating: 9.8
  • Designer cottage with amazing view, serene deck & outdoor shower - walk to beach.- Review Count: 24, Rating: 9.6
  • Beach Cottage on Fire Island.- Review Count: 22, Rating: 10.0