Cozy Cottages in Montauk

Best Cottage Rentals in Montauk

Experience the beauty of Montauk with our selection of delightful cottages, perfect for travelers seeking tranquility and style. Each listing promises a unique getaway experience.

Cottages in Montauk
Montauk Tranquil Cottage on Fort Pond
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Watch the sunrise and set over Fort Pond with the beautiful Hamlet of Montauk as a back drop.
A stunning vista view filled with sun, stars and nature.
The perfect place to unwind for one person or a couple.

Guest Reviews:

- "Hosts couldn’t have been more helpful, communicative and welcoming. Loved our week in the cottage and plan to be back soon! What a great location and the process with Michael and Vicky was seamless." - "We had a very enjoyable week in a very lovely setting by the pond. The cottage is beautiful and we look forward to coming back. Michael and Vicky are great hosts."

Cottages in Montauk
Private Beach access 4 bedroom house in the beautiful Culloden neighborhood
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Enjoy your stay at our beautiful beach house, with private beach access. This 4-bedroom beach house is located in the beautiful Culloden Shores neighborhood, walking & biking distance to the shops & restaurants. We have a large living room & outdoor area, so there will be plenty of room to spread out and relax. The property features a washer/dryer machine, TV's in every room, outdoor shower, bikes & BBQ.

Amenities:

Internet • Security/Safety • Wellness Facilities • Bedding/Linens • Fireplace/Heating • Air Conditioner • Laundry • Child Friendly

Cottages in Montauk
Waterfront Cottage Perfection
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Perfect Sunsets any time of year —this magical two-bedroom waterfront cottage on bucolic Fort Pond is as close as it gets to perfection. Every room looks out upon the most beautiful waterfront and sunset vistas all year. A designer's home is beautifully decorated with mid-century modern furniture and spectacular landscaping, enhancing the privacy felt on this gem of a property. It features a large living area with ribbon remote control gas fireplace, a dining table, a state-of-the-art kitchen, sofa and a bathroom with a large glass-enclosed rain head shower with access to the outdoor shower from the inside. Ideal for couples, singles, or small families (dogs accepted with a $250 fee, and crated when left alone). Maximum sleeping capacity 4 people. (The sofa should not used for overnight guests and the backs do not go down). The cottage has plenty of outdoor furniture, a table for 8, a gas Weber grill, and stairs to the water—perfect for standup paddleboards or kayaking. A short walk to town (5 minutes), the best restaurants, the Jitney, and beaches

The cottage comes with linens, towels, beach towels, a fully equipped kitchen, and many beautiful pieces of vintage table settings and glassware for entertaining. (2) standup paddleboards, (2) Kayaks, and (2) bikes. You will be asked to sign a waiver for the use of the equipment.

The cottage is thoroughly cleaned and disinfected between each guest. All surfaces are disinfected with Clorox. All white linens are washed in warm water with bleach. All throw pillows and throws are washable and are cleaned between each guest.

$250 per week for cleaning and garbage removal. Excessive garbage will be an additional $75.
$250 Pet Fee per dog, maximum 2 dogs.
No Cats

East Hampton/Montauk Rental Registry Certificate Number 22-550 (2025)

Guest Reviews:

- "Wonderful property" - "My family and I loved our stay. The house was beautiful and very welcoming. The view and the yard were delightful. Nothing but good things to say about this property and location." - "The cottage is just beautiful. Peaceful, gorgeous view and perfect location. Highly recommend!" - "Laura is a wonderful host. Her cottage is beautiful and clean and the perfect place to relax and enjoy Montauk!" - "Lovely home would stay again for sure!"

Cottages in Montauk
Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included.
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Bring your Surf or Paddle Boards!!!! And walk down your semi-private path (shared with only four homes) to one of the most pristine white sandy beaches in Montauk. Imagine not having to deal with Ditch Plains parking! But Beach passes are included to explore other Town beaches, both ocean, and bay, as permitted (a $600 value) The two-bedroom cottage with an open living room with 180-degree views of the ocean (1) King and (1) Queen. It's a short distance to town (you can walk) and is near some of the best restaurants. It's tastefully decorated with TV and WiFi. Ideal for couples or small families. There is outdoor furniture, a table for 6, and a gas grill. This is directly across the street from the ocean. This cottage is on a hill, so you have great 180 degree ocean views and can hear the water from the deck.

7 night rental week begins Friday at 4 pm and ends Friday at 11:00 am. 3-6 night rental must end on a Friday or Monday. There are no early check-in or late check-out times unless the manager can accommodate them.

Pet fee $250 per dog per week. Only small to medium size dogs. No cats or other animals.

Guest Reviews:

- "Perfect cottage for my friends for a long weekend. We loved that beach chairs were available and the outdoor shower. The host was very responsive." - "The cottage is in a great location- a short walk to town, as well as to the beach. The cottage is well stocked, comfortable and clean. Would definitely stay there again!" - "Great views and location." - "To celebrate a graduation, our family stayed in Montauk as a base to explore Long Island. The ocean view from the cottage was excellent, the amenities were great for the four of us, and Jeanne was a great and responsive host."

Cottages in Montauk
Ditch Plains Beach Cottage- Walk to Beach
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

WALK TO THE BEACH- never deal with limited or restricted beach parking. Ride your bike or walk to the beach throughout the day

Cleaned and disinfected to the highest standards. Weekly cleanings are required for any stay longer than one week.

Super Cute 2 bedroom cottage that overlooks a nature preserve sleeps 4. It's Just 3 short blocks to the iconic Ditch Plains beach. Features a new modern kitchen that spills out to the front and rear decks and back yard where you can enjoy cooking on a new weber grill and lounge on the outdoor furniture. The deck also has an outdoor shower. Each bedroom features a queen bed (one bed being a tempurpedic) with Egyptian cotton sheets and down pillows. Both bedroom come with ample closet space. There is a Bose bluetooth sound system, Wifi, Cable and Apple TV. Four bicycles are provided for easy cruising to the beach or to town. Beach chairs, beach umbrella and beach wagon are included.

A security camera is located at the driveway entrance for your safety and security.

Cancellation Policy: Cancellations permitted with a 10% fee plus the amount of any revenue shortfall from a successful re-renting. We strongly encourage renter to purchase travelers insurance as a means of payment protection.

EH Reg. 22-483

Guest Reviews:

- "great" - "We had a great week in Montauk. This little house is perfect - its adorable, has everything you need, in a great location, and most importantly it was very clean. Plus, it is pet friendly. Its really hard to find pet friendly rentals that check all those other boxes too! The host was very responsive to messages. I really appreciated the welcome letter with lots of great suggestions, which we referred to often. They have chairs, umbrellas, bikes, boogie boards, everything you need to enjoy the beach. I always appreciate not having to pack linens, so the fact that there were sheets, towels, and beach towels was amazing. I would absolutely rent this property again. We hope to come back soon to experience the off season - it was very crowded the week we were there, with long wait times at most restaurants almost every night. Plan accordingly! I would just point out to fellow dog owners, the yard is not entirely fenced in. It's mostly fenced, but there are points of egress alongside the house and a small dog can easily go underneath in certain places. There's also lots of wildlife to chase, so we ended up leashing our dog in the yard to be on the safe side. This was not a big deal although it was a little bit of a bummer. 10/10, would rent again!"

Cottages in Montauk
Ocean View White Cottage Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

This ocean view cottage is directly across the street from the beach. Bring your Surf or Paddle Boards!!!! And walk down (200 yards) your semi-private path (shared with only four homes) to one of the most pristine white sandy beaches in Montauk. Imagine not having to deal with Ditch Plains parking! But a Beach pass is included ($500 value) to explore other Town ocean and bay beaches as permitted! This cottage with two bedrooms has an updated open living and dining area. It's a short distance to town (you can walk) and is near some of the best restaurants. It's beautifully decorated and includes TV and WiFi for remote work. Ideal for couples or small families. There is outdoor furniture, a table for 6, and a Nexgrill gas grill.

7-night rentals begin Friday at 4 pm and end the following Friday at 11:00, except for Monthly rentals. 3-6 night rentals end on a Friday or a Monday.

Sorry, no pets at all including dogs.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a fantastic stay at this oceanview cottage! Everything was as promised in the listing. The house was impeccably clean and our host Jeanne was super responsive and had everything ready for us. The house is right across from the beach - you can't ask for a better location. A great trip looking forward to doing it again!" - "Great location, cute and clean." - "This cottage on the water is fantastic. Steps away from the beach, cozy cottage, all new amenities, and a great host. Perfect location close to everything. We had an amazing stay."

Cottages in Montauk
1000 Feet From Our Door Step To The Atlantic Ocean
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Our cozy two-bedroom one bath cottage is perfect for a family, or can accommodate up to six people very comfortably. It has central heat and air conditioning, with hardwood floors. You will love the closeness of the ocean and the Lake in downtown Montauk. No need for a car. Close to all services that Montauk provides for it's guests. Parking in front for three cars, and a huge backyard for throwing the perfect outdoor party. Just bring your bathing suits and sandals and you will fit right in. We also have an outdoor shower experience, gas barbecue, and fire pit in the backyard for relaxation under the stars!

PLACES TO EAT

Duryea's:
Food served mostly family style & ordered through a counter window (drinks ordered tableside)
Lobster cobb salad & market fish are menu highlights (they had a branzino last time I was there and it was TDF) No reservations - on weekends, get there around 5 and expect a wait for large parties unless you want to just do cold seafood inside at the bar (oysters, shrimp, etc.). Grab some rose and wait for your table on the dock. Weekday evenings and lunch are usually a bit slower but the place is generally always busy.

Scarpetta Beach:
Same as Scarpetta in NYC, traditional Italian food, inside Gurney's hotel.

Crows Nest:
Super chic restaurant at a boutique hotel, one of my favorite places. Mostly Mediterranean inspired, simple menu. No reservations - like Duryeas, on weekends, get there between 5-6 and expect a wait for large parties. They usually cut the waiting list off at a certain point (have waited upwards of 2 hours for dinner here before). Weekday evenings should be more low-key but the closer to the weekend you are the more likely there will be a long wait.
They have a cute bar down the hill in the bag with a small beach and cabanas set up. Go down and have a drink while you wait for your table and watch the sunset (spicy tequila or watermelon drinks are my favorites).

Surf Lodge:
The quintessential Montauk hotspot. Food is ok, this is more of a place to go to be part of the "scene."
On the weekends this turns into a full-on club - insanely difficult doorman, bottle service, outside DJ (until ~9), sweaty inside bar. Sometimes they have live music on Saturday / Sundays for sunset hours.

Montauket:
BEST SUNSET IN MONTAUK. Very casual spot with a divey inside bar and picnic tables outside.

Gosman's:
Casual seafood spot with a bar - a traditional Montauk staple (not scenery).
No reservations, so again, expect a wait unless you show up early or during the week.

Navy Beach:
Beach front, nautical vibe with lots of white and blue. Food is okay but it's another one of those places sceny NYC people tend to talk about.
I think they take reservations.

Showfish:
Seafood restaurant at the other Gurney's property on Star Island. Food is pretty good, traditional. Not really a scene.
I think they take reservations

Joni's:
Great a little breakfast spot off the main town road.

Round Swamp Farm:
Montauk outpost of the East Hampton Farmstand (overpriced but love it)

Sel Rose:
Oysters and cocktails.

Harvest On Fort Pond:
Outdoor dining, amazing food.

The Dock:
Montauks best dive bar, super fun, almost tacky vibe, and great food.

Montauk Bake Shoppe:
For jelly croissants.

BEACHES & HIKES

Gurney's:
The best beach is the one by Gurneys. The beach is technically public, but they won't let you park on the Gurney's property unless you have a reservation and you won't be able to use their beach chairs. If you want to have a splurge day, rent a cabana or seating area for an afternoon. Sometimes they have a DJ playing on the weekends. Full-service world-class spa on the property.

Ditch Plains Beach:
The Most popular beach for surfing and swimming. Scenic, sort of has a coastal California feel.

Kirk Park Beach:
Closest to town, family-oriented

Hither Hills:
Trails and campgrounds

Montauk Point / Camp Hero:
Scenic lighthouse at the end of the road / gift shop with some trails around. Be careful hiking there are tons of ticks.

SHOPS

Shops in town are mostly of the beachy variety (think Jersey shore hoodies and sweats kind of stuff). In the last ~5 years they've opened a bunch more stores but mostly womenswear.

Whalebone / Adam Mar has some men's stuff I think and there is this new super hip store called wyld blue that is fun to browse.
Some places in town offer surf lessons or paddle board / kayak rentals (you might also be able to book a reservation through Gurney's)

Deep Hollow Ranch - horse back riding, etc. - never been here but just saw some brand do an influencer activation and it looked cute.

Guest Reviews:

- "Great house, with an amazing location. Was easy to walk into the center of town. House has a great outdoor shower." - "The cottage is located is the best location to the beach and the town! Perfect for everything! Beautiful rooms and spacious also a great outdoor space to relax or do bonfire. Large bathroom which is helpful with kids. Robert was very responsive to any questions we had." - "Can’t beat the location. Across the street from the beach and a 2 minute walk from town. Will definitely stay again!"

Cottages in Montauk
Oceanfront, Private Beach, Outdoor Shower, Indoor Heated Pool, Wifi, Grill
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Perfect for a family or artist getaway, this charming, renovated, 1940-built cottage offers comfort, privacy, and unforgettable ocean views. With two bedrooms and one-and-a-half baths, it comfortably sleeps six. For larger groups, a pull-out sofa in the open concept living room can accommodate two additional guests, bringing the total capacity to eight.

Come relax in the indoor heated pool, or soak in the scenery from the spacious ocean-view deck. The renovated cottage is completely private, surrounded by hedges and separated from the rest of the complex—your own hidden retreat.

Modern conveniences include a newly renovated kitchen with all-new appliances and dishwasher, flat-screen cable TV, Wi-Fi, and even an outdoor shower for post-beach rinses. Best of all, you'll have exclusive access to a private ocean beach just steps away.

You have all the amenities of the Wavecrest Resort, such as Indoor heated pool with lifeguard. Beach boy for lounges and umbrellas. Food truck for excellent breakfasts and lunches. Shuffle Board and outdoor shower on the beach. Most of all a beautiful white sandy beach for Swimming, surfing and exploring for Sea shells and beach glass.
A complete vacation experience awaits your arrival!
“And the Sea, shall bring each man new hope!”

PLACES TO EAT IN MONTAUK

Duryea's:
Food served mostly family style & ordered through a counter window (drinks ordered tableside)
Lobster cobb salad & market fish are menu highlights (they had a branzino last time I was there and it was TDF) No reservations - on weekends, get there around 5 and expect a wait for large parties unless you want to just do cold seafood inside at the bar (oysters, shrimp, etc.). Grab some rose and wait for your table on the dock. Weekday evenings and lunch are usually a bit slower but the place is generally always busy.

Scarpetta Beach:
Same as Scarpetta in NYC, traditional Italian food, inside Gurney's hotel.

Crows Nest:
Super chic restaurant at a boutique hotel, one of my favorite places. Mostly Mediterranean inspired, simple menu. No reservations - like Duryeas, on weekends, get there between 5-6 and expect a wait for large parties. They usually cut the waiting list off at a certain point (have waited upwards of 2 hours for dinner here before). Weekday evenings should be more low-key but the closer to the weekend you are the more likely there will be a long wait.
They have a cute bar down the hill in the bag with a small beach and cabanas set up. Go down and have a drink while you wait for your table and watch the sunset (spicy tequila or watermelon drinks are my favorites).

Surf Lodge:
The quintessential Montauk hotspot. Food is ok, this is more of a place to go to be part of the "scene."
On the weekends this turns into a full-on club - insanely difficult doorman, bottle service, outside DJ (until ~9), sweaty inside bar. Sometimes they have live music on Saturday / Sundays for sunset hours.

Montauket:
BEST SUNSET IN MONTAUK. Very casual spot with a divey inside bar and picnic tables outside.

Gosman's:
Casual seafood spot with a bar - a traditional Montauk staple (not sceney).
No reservations, so again, expect a wait unless you show up early or during the week.

Navy Beach:
Beach front, nautical vibe with lots of white and blue. Food is okay but it's another one of those places sceny NYC people tend to talk about.
I think they take reservations.

Showfish:
Seafood restaurant at the other Gurney's property on Star Island. The food is pretty good, traditional. Not really a scene.
I think they take reservations

Joni's:
Great little breakfast spot off the main town road.

Round Swamp Farm:
Montauk outpost of the East Hampton Farmstand (overpriced but love it)

Sel Rose:
Oysters and cocktails.

Harvest On Fort Pond:
Outdoor dining, amazing food.

The Dock:
Montauks best dive bar, super fun, almost tacky vibe, and great food.

Montauk Bake Shoppe:
For jelly croissants.

BEACHES & HIKES

Gurney's:
The best beach is the one by Gurneys. The beach is technically public, but they won't let you park on the Gurney's property unless you have a reservation and you won't be able to use their beach chairs. If you want to have a splurge day, rent a cabana or seating area for an afternoon. Sometimes they have a DJ playing on the weekends. Full-service world-class spa on the property.

Ditch Plains Beach:
Most popular beach for surfing and swimming. Scenic, sort of has a coastal California feel.

Kirk Park Beach:
Closest to town, family-oriented

Hither Hills:
Trails and campgrounds

Montauk Point / Camp Hero:
Scenic lighthouse at the end of the road / gift shop with some trails around. Be careful hiking there are tons of ticks.

SHOPS

Shops in town are mostly of the beachy variety (think Jersey shore hoodies and sweats kind of stuff). In the last ~5 years, they've opened a bunch more stores but mostly womenswear.

Whalebone / Adam Mar has some men's stuff I think and there is this new super hip store called wyld blue that is fun to browse.
Some places in town offer surf lessons or paddle board / kayak rentals (you might also be able to book a reservation through Gurney's)

Deep Hollow Ranch - horse back riding, etc. - never been here but just saw some brand do an influencer activation and it looked cute.

Guest Reviews:

- "Very close to montauk bars, right on the beach, it was great" - "Easy communication with owner description very accurate Would return but cannot imagine sharing with another couple" - "The cottage was perfect for my small family and our dog. It was super clean, great location and adorable vibe. We will definitely be back! " - "This adorable, cozy cottage was perfect for our family getaway to Montauk. We have tried various rentals and hotels each summer and Robert’s cottage was by far our favorite. It fit our family of 5 perfectly, with enough room that we didn’t feel on top of each other. The decor was light and airy and just what we were hoping to find. From the awesome location, just a walk to the ocean, to the indoor pool and back up to a comfortable stay, our entire family agree that we can’t wait to return! Communication was easy and Robert was the best host we have had. Thank you for a great stay! You made the end of our summer one we will always cherish. "

Cottages in Montauk
Steps to the beach! Enjoy Hither Hills only private beach. 7 day minimum
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

68 Madison is a 5 min. walk to the beach. The private beach in Hither Hills is know as one of Montauks finest. Town is about 1 mile away too. There is a resturaunt within walking distance. The house is located on a corner lot and is very private due to the hedges. There are three large sceen TV's in the house and a well appointed kitchen. The washer and dryer are in the basement. Herb garden, Tomatoes and squash will be ready for harvest!
There is a 7 day minimum and booking start on Saturdays

Guest Reviews:

- "Second time staying at this house. Host is extremely accommodating. House is very nice and the location is perfect. Thank you!" - "Beautiful home. Close to town and beach. Owner was very thoughtful and house stocked with everything! Only issue was refrigerator door and top shelf were filled with items. We bring a lot out so it was tough to find room. Overall one of the nicest homes we have rented. Thank you Chris." - "Beautiful spot , cannot beat the private ocean beach access and proximity to town. Our favorite spot the covered deck , spent long mornings there. Ryan and Chris responded very quickly to a (gasp) Wi-Fi issue! All resolved - love this place and would definitely rent again!"

Cottages in Montauk
SEPTEMER Serenity - Charming 3 Bedroom Beach House
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

House is walking distance to pristine unspoiled private beach. Total privacy as the house is situated on a large lot at the end of a dead end street. Visitors can walk to vibrant downtown business district with tons of shops and restaurants. Beautiful, bright and sunny three bedrooms (two bedrooms have walkout decks), two bath beach house. Brand new kitchen/bathrooms and spacious living area. Expansive decks wrapping around the house overlooking wide open spaces for children to play.
With this HITHER HILLS home, you will get a parking pass and key to obtain access to our own beautiful private beach. Only the small community of HITHER HILLS residents and renters have access to the beach

East Hampton Rental Registry Certificate # 19-670

Guest Reviews:

- "We spent a great week at the house. The host was wonderful and provided everything we needed. There were plenty of games for children, beach chairs and bikes. We would love to come back." - "Kay’s lovely home was everything we needed plus more for our long stay. The house was beautiful and tucked away on a dead end street and is a 10 minute walk to the beach. She was very easy to get in contact with which made the stay even more enjoyable. The private beach access was amazing!"

Cottages in Montauk
Cozy cottage on Fort Pond Lake.
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Quaint 1 bedroom situated in the heart of Montauk. Walk to town, Navy Beach, or the Surf Lodge. Fully renovated to accommodate 1 - 4 people. Cottage has 1 bedroom, living room with full sized sleeper-sofa, kitchen , bathroom and outdoor patio with ample yard facing the lake. Accommodations includes BBQ, air conditioning, fire pit, 2 kayaks, Bikes ,WiFi & cable TV. Bring surf boards , Bikes, Toys - access to locked storage on property . Centrally located, family-fun is only steps away! We also offer nightly discounts for guest who stay a minimum 7 days or longer .

Guest Reviews:

- "Our stay in the property was perfect! The house had huge windows overlooking the lake, and the outside area had plenty of spots to sit and relax. The house was so clean and equipped with everything we needed. The location was perfect, and we were walking distance to some spots like Navy Beach and the Surf Lodge. There were plenty of bikes for us to ride as well. Definitely recommend staying here!" - "We couldn’t have had a better stay. The cottage was cozy and the yard right on the lake was perfect for kayaking, grilling, morning coffee or an evening drink, and hanging around the fire pit. WiFi was sufficient for working from home. Convenient location close to town - walkable if you want to get a little exercise in, and very short walk to music at the Surf Lodge. Thank you, Danny for sharing the cottage with us! "

Cottages in Montauk
Cottage On Lake Montauk
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Adorable one bedroom cottage that has been totally renovated. Located in a small community located on 2 acres of scenic property on lake . A short stroll down to the lake where you can fish ,clam ,swim and kayak .Deck with table chairs and umbrella with views of the lake. Cottage has air conditioner,full kitchen with plates,utensils,pots sheets and towels .one queen and bunk beds,and option of pull out couch in living sleep up to 4 .can bike to gin or ditch beach.This area is a quiet area that works well for peace and tranquility ,it is not suitable for parties .This property is perfect for couples,families and fishermen .The sunsets at the lake are worth watching!

Guest Reviews:

- "Comfy and quiet with view of Montauk Lake." - "We loved our stay and were very comfortable. Beautiful location, quiet and low key, and the cottage was really cozy and cute. Had everything we needed. We are a family of four who are used to traveling together and sharing a room so for us it was perfect. Host is very attentive, responds really quickly. Highly recommend." - "Went on a last minute mini vacation with my husband. Had a wonderful time. If you’re looking for an affordable, peaceful and clean stay in Montauk, I highly recommend this place! It’s just a short walk to the lake and close to town. Christine the host was very pleasant and accommodating. She was always available and quick to respond. I will definitely be going back to Montauk and staying here!"

Cottages in Montauk
Hither Hills 2BR Montauk Cottage - walk to beach!
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Two bedroom/ 1 bath cottage located in coveted Hither Hills. Cottage includes shared^ key access to private parking lots along Old Montauk Highway that access a mile of private sandy ocean beach under the supervision of the Montauk Beach Property Owners Association, (MBPOA).

As per East Hampton rental laws our minimum stay is 15 days. We are also happy to have you as our guest for longer stays (monthly, etc). Thank you for your interest in our cottage!

**Pls note: towels and bed linens are not provided for our home rental. You will need to bring your own for your stay.**
^Beach key is shared with our other cottage next door.
Rental Registry #: 20-1,262

Guest Reviews:

- "Great small cottage a few blocks from the beach. Has everything you need. Beach pass is a plus. Very responsive host." - "Had a great time staying here." - "Very cute house and full stocked kitchen. We enjoyed our stay." - "This cottage is super charming. It was bigger than we had expected. Perfect for two people and an occasional visitor as the 2nd bedroom is bunkbeds. The back-deck is great to hang. Close to town. We'll be back!"

Cottages in Montauk
Renovated Beach Cottage ~ Walk/Bike To Montauk Village
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Beautiful Montauk Beach Cottage renovated in 2019-20: Walk/bike to center village, Montauk town beach, and Fort Pond Bay/Navy Beach. Brand new chef’s kitchen w/ new appliances and island. Upgraded full bathroom, new wood stove fireplace, new mahogany deck w/patio furniture and BBQ grill, stone patio w/ gas fire pit, outside shower, new washer/dryer, and high-speed WiFi.

There are 2 bedrooms - one with a queen bed and the other with two twins, and a sofa sleeper in family room, sleeping 6 people comfortably. New AC’s in family room and both bedrooms. Large TV in family room and TV’s in bedrooms. There is an unfinished basement w/ laundry room. Includes cable and WiFi.

Guest Reviews:

- "This house was perfect for a fall get away! It was very comfortable and in a great location!" - "We had a wonderful time at the cottage! Scott made sure we had everything we needed and also provided us with bikes for our stay. The cottage has a great location. Close to the main beach, tray and town." - "We had a great time staying at Scott's place. He was super helpful whenever we had any issues. Highly recommend!" - "My family and I stayed at this beach cottage for a long weekend a few weekends ago and loved it! Excellent location, short walk to town and beaches. The house itself has everything you need for a quick weekend away, the back patio was great for grilling, and there was an excellent seafood shack right next door to grab fresh seafood.. The owner Scott was extremely helpful, welcoming, and made the check-in and check-out process extremely easy. He even left some refreshments in the fridge for us for our arrival! Overall great spot and experience, and will definitely come back!"

Cottages in Montauk
Newly Renovated Cottage Across from the Ocean, Walk or Hampton Hopper to Town!
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

This newly renovated cottage sits right across from the ocean, you can hear the waves even with the windows closed!

This guest cottage sits on a flag lot behind the master house, conveniently located right on the Hampton Hopper’s nearly hourly route! Or, if you feel like a stroll, town is less than a mile away. You can even walk to the beach across the street, and enjoy car-free living in Montauk!

The cottage features two bedrooms, one with an incredibly comfortable queen mattress, and one spare room equipped with a Twin XL trundle.

The kitchen is FULLY equipped for ANY sort of cooking you may want to do, including a full line of Breville appliances, as well as an electric range and oven. A GE ice maker will also be running providing excellent drink ice from filtered water.

The retro Smeg fridge is capable of holding anything you may bring home, while still being stylish in its Union Jack uniform.

The down stuffed sectional couch is plenty comfortable, and can also sleep one guest if need be.

A washer and dryer closet is fully stocked, and new, along with all the other appliances in the cottage.

Please feel free to book the cottage, knowing full well we will be nearby to support you in any means necessary to enjoy your stay!

Amenities:

Bedding/Linens • Pet Friendly • Laundry • Air Conditioner • Kitchen • Internet • Tv • Balcony/Terrace • Child Friendly

Cottages in Montauk
Newly Listed The Sunlit Cozy Cottage by the Sea on Lake Montauk
Cottage
montauk, New York, USA

The Cottage is on 2 acres on scenic East Lake Drive directly on Lake Montauk .Our Cottage is a bright,cheery,sunlit space that is a lovely place to enjoy your dream vacation and best of all you have your own private beach in the backyard where you can relax,swim,kayak,fish,clam or just enjoy a beautiful Montauk sunset. All the best Montauk has to offer. Most everything for a fun filled dream vacation is here. There is one bedroom with 2 twin beds that can be put together as a king if needed.There is a queen size sleeper sofa in the living room and a fully equipted kitchen. Heat, A.C. LCD high def T.V cable, computer with WiFi, beautiful wrap around deck with table, chairs, umbrella, garden bench, and propane grill and A beach pass to visit all of the Hamptons and Montauk famous beaches. Ditch Plains, Montauk Point, Gin beach, Navy beach, Kirk park beach just to name a few
********Big full season and summer season discount ask ********
************* Book early, booking 2024 - 2026 season now ***********

MD - LD summer season May 1ST - Oct 30TH big discount ask about season discount
The Cottage is located about 2 miles east of town .It is with in walking distance of the famous surfing beach Ditch Plains , or a breezy night you can hear the surf breaking off in the distance from ditch plains out on the deck and 3.5 miles from Montauk Point and the famous Montauk Lighthouse that George Waskington commissioned in 1792.We are 2.4 miles from Ginbeach and .7 miles from the Montauk Lake Club on 2 nicely maintained acres directly on the water.

We are located directly on Montauk bay (lake Montauk) just steps from your own private beach out back.

Guest Reviews:

- "We had a great week in Montauk and this house was a great place to stay for our purposes. We wanted a "home" to come back to at the end of the day and this was it! We were very comfortable, were able to bbq and cook a few nights, as well as do all of the Montauk sites and activities we had on our agenda. I plan to contact the owner again for future visits. Highly recommend - the property and house were clean, well-maintained and everything was in working order."

Cottages in Montauk
Montauk Sunset Cottage overlooking Garden! Walk to Train, Montauket and Duryea's
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Brand new 2 bedroom 1 bathroom first floor apartment overlooking a charming garden. Separate entrance, with dedicated parking area. Private bay beach access. Walk to Montauket and Duryea's and train. Gorgeous new bathroom and kitchenette with dishwasher, cute outdoor seating area with small grill, couch, overlooking garden. Wifi/Apple TV incl.

Currently avail 2022 - 7 night minimum (Thrs to Thursday or Fri to Fri) discounts for longer stays.

Guest Reviews:

- "My stay was great! Perfect place if you know Montauk. Right down the street from Montauket, Duryaes, and Robertas. Never had any issues and anytime I had questions they were quickly answered. Highly recommend"

Cottages in Montauk
Charming Hither House West Cottage! Fully Furnished and Pet Friendly! nn
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

This Montauk HIther House West Cottage boasts 1 inviting bedroom with 1 queen bed and 1 twin bed. The cozy space includes essential amenities like an iron, hair dryer, heating, AC, and WiFi. The bathroom is equipped with a hair dryer for your convenience. Immerse yourself in the fantastic and tranquil atmosphere of this superb retreat. Book now and enjoy everything this cottage has to offer.

Hither House WestCottage, a retreat near the beaches of Montauk NY and Pet Friendly!
Vacation retreat in Montauk! Welcome to the Hither House Cottage, your perfect vacation retreat and Pet Friendly! Our charming cottage is located just a stone throw away from the beautiful beaches of Montauk, making it an ideal spot for relaxing getaway. Pending on the availability, this cottage is available all year round. Hither House Cottage is located just a few blocks to the Atlantic Ocean, one mile to the Village of Montauk, five minutes to great fishing, golf, tennis, horseback riding, restaurants, and nightlife, and only 15 minutes to East Hampton. Hither House Cottage has a picturesque setting on a hill an full amenity will attract many return visits. There is also a representative on site 24/7.
During Check-In, you will be required to sign additional House & Pet Rules which are applied to the Cottage. A Credit Card On File Will Be Required with a Valid ID. Should your stay encompass any damages, your credit on file will be use to satisfy the any applicable damages and used as a security deposit.

We provide the following Amenities:
* 5 Minute Walk to Private Hither Hills Beach.
* Parking Permits for Guest (With Deposit/Policy Guidelines)
*Wi-Fi
* Cable TV/HBO
*Fully Equipped Kitchen
*Wood Burning Fire Place
*BBQ Grill
* Out Door Furniture/Lounge Chairs
* Fire Pits
*Outdoor Shower
*Daily Upkeeping Services (Trash Removal, Replacing Towels, Provide Cleaning Supplies)

Activities in Montauk: Also Visit Montauk Chamber of Commerce for Additional Information.
https://montaukchamber.com/

* Montauk Light House, Precious Beacon
*Beaches-Oceans, Bays and Sound
*World Class Golf at Montauk Downs-Robert Trent Jones Course
*Horseback Riding Through the Nature Trails and on the Beach
*Party Boat Fishing, Charter Boat- With Montauk Season Captains
*Whale Watching- Take a Trip from Montauk Harbor in the Summer Months for the Best Sightings
*Nature Hikes Through the Thousands Preserved Acres
*Bike Tours -Off Road and Rentals
*Shopping
* Fine & Casual Dinning with Waterfront Fine Dinning

Amenities:

Child Friendly • Air Conditioner • Other • Laundry • Internet • Wellness Facilities • Fireplace/Heating • Pet Friendly • Security/Safety • Bedding/Linens

Cottages in Montauk
Hither House Cottage, a retreat near the beaches of Montauk NY and Pet Friendly!
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Vacation retreat in Montauk! Welcome to the Hither House Cottage, your perfect vacation retreat and Pet Friendly! Our charming cottage is located just a stone throw away from the beautiful beaches of Montauk, making it an ideal spot for relaxing getaway. Pending on the availability, this cottage is available all year round. Hither House Cottage is located just a few blocks to the Atlantic Ocean, one mile to the Village of Montauk, five minutes to great fishing, golf, tennis, horseback riding, restaurants, and nightlife, and only 15 minutes to East Hampton. Hither House Cottage has a picturesque setting on a hill an full amenity will attract many return visits. There is also a representative on site 24/7.
During Check-In, you will be required to sign additional House & Pet Rules which are applied to the Cottage. A Credit Card On File Will Be Required with a Valid ID. Should your stay encompass any damages, your credit on file will be use to satisfy the any applicable damages and used as a security deposit.

We provide the following Amenities:
* 5 Minute Walk to Private Hither Hills Beach.
* Parking Permits for Guest (With Deposit/Policy Guidelines)
*Wi-Fi
* Cable TV/HBO
*Fully Equipped Kitchen
*Wood Burning Fire Place
*BBQ Grill
* Out Door Furniture/Lounge Chairs
* Fire Pits
*Outdoor Shower
*Daily Upkeeping Services (Trash Removal, Replacing Towels, Provide Cleaning Supplies)

Activities in Montauk: Also Visit Montauk Chamber of Commerce for Additional Information.
https://montaukchamber.com/

* Montauk Light House, Precious Beacon
*Beaches-Oceans, Bays and Sound
*World Class Golf at Montauk Downs-Robert Trent Jones Course
*Horseback Riding Through the Nature Trails and on the Beach
*Party Boat Fishing, Charter Boat- With Montauk Season Captains
*Whale Watching- Take a Trip from Montauk Harbor in the Summer Months for the Best Sightings
*Nature Hikes Through the Thousands Preserved Acres
*Bike Tours -Off Road and Rentals
*Shopping
* Fine & Casual Dinning with Waterfront Fine Dinning

Guest Reviews:

- "We have spent a very nice time in the Hither House. Very quiet and Montauk and the beach can be accessed within a few minutes. "

Cottages in Montauk
Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town
Cottage
Montauk, New York, USA

Charming, low key, tranquil one-bedroom beach cottage set around lush courtyard back from shore of Fort Pond with glimpse of ocean past it
Cottage drenched in light has full kitchen, patio w outdoor shower, full bath with mosaic floors, living room with big country table, bedroom with door onto patio.

Part of a unique compound of historic fishing cottages relocated to Fort Pond ( house is 200 feet from shore) after the 1939 hurricane.
Go to sleep to the sound of the ocean and wake to the sound of birds.

Amenities:

Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking • Oceanfront • Internet • Ocean View • Kitchen • Bedding/Linens • Parking • Balcony/Terrace • View • Security/Safety • Fireplace/Heating • Other

Montauk Family Friendly Cottages

Montauk Cottages with Parking

Montauk Pet Friendly Cottages

Montauk Cottages with Entertainment

Montauk Cottages on the Map

Compare the Best Cottages in Montauk – Addresses, Prices, Stars, Rating, and Review Count

Property Name Address Price ($) Star Rating Review Count Book
Montauk Tranquil Cottage on Fort Pond Montauk, New York, USA 472 2.0 10.0 2 Click here
Private Beach access 4 bedroom house in the beautiful Culloden neighborhood Montauk, New York, USA 683 2.0 1 Click here
Waterfront Cottage Perfection Montauk, New York, USA 449 10.0 172 Click here
Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included. Montauk, New York, USA 420 10.0 79 Click here
Ditch Plains Beach Cottage- Walk to Beach Montauk, New York, USA 526 9.8 78 Click here
Ocean View White Cottage Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included Montauk, New York, USA 492 9.8 49 Click here
1000 Feet From Our Door Step To The Atlantic Ocean Montauk, New York, USA 999 4.62 40 Click here
Oceanfront, Private Beach, Outdoor Shower, Indoor Heated Pool, Wifi, Grill Montauk, New York, USA 1072 8.8 28 Click here
Steps to the beach! Enjoy Hither Hills only private beach. 7 day minimum Montauk, New York, USA 1089 10.0 24 Click here
SEPTEMER Serenity - Charming 3 Bedroom Beach House Montauk, New York, USA 926 9.6 23 Click here
Cozy cottage on Fort Pond Lake. Montauk, New York, USA 303 10.0 18 Click here
Cottage On Lake Montauk Montauk, New York, USA 457 9.6 14 Click here
Hither Hills 2BR Montauk Cottage - walk to beach! Montauk, New York, USA 119 9.8 9 Click here
Renovated Beach Cottage ~ Walk/Bike To Montauk Village Montauk, New York, USA 668 5.0 9 Click here
Newly Renovated Cottage Across from the Ocean, Walk or Hampton Hopper to Town! Montauk, New York, USA 399 4.6 5 Click here
Newly Listed The Sunlit Cozy Cottage by the Sea on Lake Montauk montauk, New York, USA 194 10.0 2 Click here
Montauk Sunset Cottage overlooking Garden! Walk to Train, Montauket and Duryea's Montauk, New York, USA 302 10.0 1 Click here
Charming Hither House West Cottage! Fully Furnished and Pet Friendly! nn Montauk, New York, USA 825 8.0 1 Click here
Hither House Cottage, a retreat near the beaches of Montauk NY and Pet Friendly! Montauk, New York, USA 1040 10.0 1 Click here
Classic Montauk Beach Cottage, Quick Walk to Beach and Town Montauk, New York, USA 488 1 Click here

Note: The prices for each Cottages in Montauk do vary. This can be because of the number of people you are booking for, how far in advance you book and the season. The prices above are only meant as a rough estimate for comparison purposes. Click the buttons above (or click here) to get the latest prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

Cottages in Montauk that include a pool or hot tub include:

  • Oceanfront, Private Beach, Outdoor Shower, Indoor Heated Pool, Wifi, Grill.- Review Count: 28, Rating: 8.8

Family-friendly cottages in Montauk include:

  • Montauk Tranquil Cottage on Fort Pond.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0
  • Private Beach access 4 bedroom house in the beautiful Culloden neighborhood .- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • Waterfront Cottage Perfection.- Review Count: 172, Rating: 10.0

Pet-friendly cottages in Montauk include:

  • Waterfront Cottage Perfection.- Review Count: 172, Rating: 10.0
  • Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included..- Review Count: 79, Rating: 10.0
  • Ditch Plains Beach Cottage- Walk to Beach.- Review Count: 78, Rating: 9.8

Cottages in Montauk that include breakfast or meal options include:

  • Luxury Montauk Waterfront Cottage with Private Spa & Sunset Views.- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0

Cottages in Montauk offering on-site parking include:

  • Montauk Tranquil Cottage on Fort Pond.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0
  • Waterfront Cottage Perfection.- Review Count: 172, Rating: 10.0
  • Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included..- Review Count: 79, Rating: 10.0

Some of the best Cottages in Montauk are:

  • Montauk Tranquil Cottage on Fort Pond.- Review Count: 2, Rating: 10.0
  • Private Beach access 4 bedroom house in the beautiful Culloden neighborhood .- Review Count: 0, Rating: 0.0
  • Waterfront Cottage Perfection.- Review Count: 172, Rating: 10.0

Some of the popular Cottages in Montauk are:

  • Waterfront Cottage Perfection.- Review Count: 172, Rating: 10.0
  • Ocean View Modern Cottage —Walk to Town, Beach Pass Included..- Review Count: 79, Rating: 10.0
  • Ditch Plains Beach Cottage- Walk to Beach.- Review Count: 78, Rating: 9.8